![]() |
||
Printed TranslationsBooks about the sources or a particular source are listed under About the Sources. Source collections | The major sources | The Alexander Romance and other stories Source collections
Reviewed by Jona Lendering, BMCR (February 2004). I think Lendering (author of livius.org) oversteps the reviewer's mandate somewhat, with too little on the book itself and too much on what he thinks should have made it in. He turns the second two thirds of the review into a mini-article on the Babylonian sources. Lengthy Amazon review by Thom Stark. Stark (who also includes a really nasty review of Bosworth's Conquest and Empire) praises the inclusion of the Metz Epitome, and other hard-to-find texts, but criticizes it for not going far enough. "The bad news, from my perspective, begins with the fact that Heckel has chosen to include only representative quotes on each of his chosen topics and has omitted to add a list of the other source citations on those topics, which I think would have considerably increased the value of this book to scholars. Instead, he has clearly aimed this work at students."
Amazon. Alexander and the Greeks by Victor Ehrenberg (1982). Ehrenberg assembled all the inscriptions associated with Alexander. The major sourcesPothos.org: Reviews of the available translations by Nick Wellman.
Plutarch's Lives VII: Alexander, Caesar, Demosthenes, Cicero. Loeb Classical Library edition with Greek text and facing English translation by Beradotte Perrin. No introduction or commentary. One Amazon reviewer's "advise": "Try to avoid any book written by Plutarch for all the lives he has written about are sketchy."
Reviewed by Stanley M. Burstein, BMCR 99.5. "Yardley's translation is a pleasure to read with its clear and accurate rendition of Justin's rhetorical Latin. Heckel's commentary has similar merits. The entries are concise and lucid. Every crux is identified and unraveled, full references are provided to parallels in the other Alexander historians, and brief but well chosen bibliographies are furnished for each chapter. To work through the commentary is to take a well-guided tour of the Alexander tradition as a whole." Reviewed by P. J. Rhodes, Histos 1998.
School text: Quintus Curtius Rufus: Alexander the Great edited by W. S. Hett (1935, Reprint 1991). $13.00 from Bolchazy-Carducci. The Alexander Romance and other storiesAmazon. The Greek Alexander Romance, translated by Richard Stoneman. This is a great edition, with an informative introduction, and forming a coherent narritive while still troubling to note where the various versions diverge.
Reviewed by Thomas M. Banchich, Canisius College for the
Bryn Mawr Classical Review.
|
![]() ![]() Check out my new site
Wiki Classical Dictionary, currently focused on Alexander |
|
All material © 20002005 Tim Spalding. Presented in Association with Amazon |
If you enjoy this site you may also like these other sites by me: Genghis Khan on the Web More than 275 links about the Mongol conqueror. Cleopatra on the Web Over 410 resources on Cleopatra. Includes 168 images. Ancient Library and the Wiki Classical Dictionray, major new reference sources for ancient studies. Hieroglyphs! Over 125 links about Egyptian hieroglyphs for all ages and levels of knowledge. |