The Spirit of the 'SAMMY-B'

by RADM Robert W. Copeland, USNR, Commanding Officer, USS SAMUEL B. ROBERTS (DE 413)

From the USS SAMUEL B. ROBERTS (DE 413) Survivor's Association

Used by permission


 

CHAPTER 7

Three 8-inch shells had hit us.

"You were approximately broadside, weren't you?"

Just about broadside and 5500 yards. We didn't have fire control radar, so we were verifying our visual ranges by surface radar ranges which were coming up from combat below to our gunnery talkers, and the last one I heard was 5500 yards.

"Why didn't you turn your stern to present a small target for the moment?"

We couldn't, Jack, and accomplish our mission. We still were primarily trying to protect and screen the carriers. If we had turned our stern we would have plowed right into our own carriers. We were in a tactical situation where we just couldn't. Besides, we couldn't have unmasked both our guns if we had done that. We could have fired from only the after-gun. It was just one of those situations; that was the only way we could do it.

When those three 8-inch shells hit us--they were all APs as nearly as I can tell from the information I gathered from our survivors--one went in and out through the IC gyro room. That's the nerve center of the ship--I mean mechanically. That's where your master gyro compass is and all of our electrical connections off your main communication board. That means, first, that right then and there the compartment was flooded. Second, the two electrician's mates who were on duty down there were drowned like rats in a trap. Third, being flooded, our master gyro was out and all of our electrical connections and that meant that we no longer had any inter-communications and this was a handicap in operating the ship. It also meant that a lot of our auxiliary power went out and we no longer had any power on our guns--no power for a multitude of things. Another 8-inch shell went through the lower handling room for our forward No. 1 gun. At that stage of the game there wasn't too much 5-inch ammunition left down there. I daresay there were only about eighty rounds remaining. One of the men who was in the handling room--his name was Farmer--told me afterwards when I talked to him on the way back to the States that the shell came in on the port side just above the water line, made a nice round hole eight inches in diameter, and went out on the starboard side about an inch or two below the water line. Of course, water started pouring in there through one hole and in a few minutes the ship was down enough so that the water was pouring in through two holes. They opened the escape hatch and somehow got the ammunition out of there, threw it into the upper handling room, then scrambled out, clamped the escape hatch closed and then while the upper handling room crew was still doing its regular job the men from below moved the salvaged shells into the chief petty officer's stateroom, and used that for an auxiliary handling room. They got all the men out. Farmer just kept on working. He told me he was the last man out, and the water was up to his armpits when he started up the ladder. Of course, they dogged the hatch down and sealed off that part of the ship. He had a lot of assistance. Chief Boatswain's Mate Wallace, who was in charge of a repair party which was stationed forward down on the first deck below the main deck, was a great deal of help to the handling crew and augmented and supplemented them with his men.

The third shell was the one that did the most damage. It came in on the main deck on the port side just below where the motor whaleboat was rigged. That particular area of the deck was over the No. 1 fire room, and right underneath that deck the main steam line went out from the boiler. The shell went in there; it didn't explode but it ruptured the main steam line. It dropped on down and apparently it hit a couple of men before it rolled on into the bilges. It killed them. And it released a terrific amount of high pressure steam into that boiler room.

In there was a young lad by the name of McCaskill. He had been an absolute flop on the deck force. He was always in trouble--always in hot water. Finally in last desperation, because he seemed like a good enough boy, the engineering officer and the first lieutenant swapped two men. The chief engineer had a man who was good enough, but he was scared. He had claustrophobia when he was down below. He wanted to be a seaman. Since McCaskill couldn't seem to make out on deck, we transferred him down to the "Black Gang." McCaskill had been in the "Black Gang" only two weeks. He was down there on the burners. We had a first-class water tender named Osborne. He was in charge of the fire room, and we had a second class water tender in there and a couple of other firemen. Everybody except McCaskill and Osborne was killed out-right when that shell hit, and poor Osborne was so badly scalded that he eventually died on one of the life rafts. I know that he suffered a lot before he died. But McCaskill, with only two weeks in the fire room, had the presence of mind to cut the fires underneath his boilers, secure what valves he could reach, cut off the air, and secure the fuel oil. Then he went over and took the telephone off of Kupidlowsky, who had been killed, put the phones on, called No. 1 engine room and told them what had happened and asked them to come and open the escape hatch so as to let some of the live steam out, Then he dove into the bilges. That's a lot of presence of mind, Jack, for a boy that was only eighteen years old and had been in the "Black Gang" for only two weeks. For his own protection he should have jumped into the bilges immediately, but he showed the proper spirit. Somewhere I have a copy of the citation I made for him to give him a silver star. That just shows you how we try to do things in the Navy. I once gave McCaskill eighty hours extra duty at Captain's Mast, which is a very severe punishment. He deserved it; he had it coming. But that was water under the bridge. McCaskill was one of the heroes of that ship and because he had been Peck's Bad Boy at one time was no reason for denying him what he had earned by his valorous conduct. I was very happy to recommend him for a silver star and see that he got it. Now that boy was so badly hurt, so badly burned, that when we were picked up I actually could see the bones on the bottom of his feet where the flesh had fallen away from them. You can realize what he went through. He was a pretty good boy.

"Did he survive?"

Yes, he survived. He was on the life raft with me, Jack, but he certainly went through the tortures of hell.

That third shell had a very disastrous effect on the ship as a whole, Jack, because where we had been making 28-1/2 knots on two boilers, the minute we lost one boiler ...

"You mean the rupturing of the steam line?"

That's right. That boiler was out; we couldn't use it any more. The main steam line from it to our engine room was gone, and that immediately cut our speed from 28-1/2 knots to 17-1/2 knots. That, you see, was even slower than the carriers were making, and it meant that we were then what you might call a "sitting duck in a shooting gallery," and we were no longer able to take advantage of extra speed and chase salvos. The time when the first salvo opened up on our Task Unit until we took our first hit--those three 8-inch shells--was exactly one hour and fifty-six minutes, under constant fire without getting hit--except for the hit on the antenna--and in a period of fifteen minutes after she got the first hit that ship was battered to pieces because we had lost most of our ability to maneuver.

The next salvo to hit us was a disastrous one from two standpoints: the personnel and the ship itself. Apparently four 8- inch shells caught us back father aft that time. One reason why our casualties were not so high was that outside of the first salvo that hit us no shells hit the bridge structure or forward. They all hit abaft the bridge structure. As you well know there was a terrific concentration of personnel in the bridge structure itself. "Where did those 8-inch shells hit?"

Exactly where those 8-inch shells hit us, we don't know. We can only base our opinions on deductive reasoning from what happened. One shell hit the after part of the deck house. The next one apparently hit at the base of the after 40-millimeter. That was a heavy gun and the mount was heavy also, almost as heavy as armor. The shell must have hit a place heavy enough in the big underpinning of that gun to explode the shell instead of letting it pass through it as it did in the skin of the ship. There was a terrific explosion and the ship shook enough to jar me up on the bridge. I turned and looked back just in time to see a whole lot of heavy white smoke lying over our fantail and to see a few objects hurtling through the air. They were the bodies of the men who had been on that gun. By the time the smoke cleared away, the gun, the gun mount, the director, and the director mount had disappeared. We never again saw Ensign LeClercq, the Assistance Gunnery Officer who was on that director; nor did we ever see the two enlisted men who were on the director with him; nor did we ever see the ten enlisted personnel who were on the gun. I can safely assume that all thirteen of them were killed outright without their ever knowing what hit them. The ship back there was left warped and twisted and blackened from the force of the explosion.

Another shell went into No. 1 engine room. That was where Mr. Trowbridge was stationed; it was the control engine room. We had some heavy "I" beams and angle irons in there that supported the main switchboard panels. Metzger, the only survivor from No. 1 engine room, told me he though an 8-inch shell had hit one of those large "I" beams in there and exploded, because there was an explosion in No. 1 engine room that just raised hell with it.

That meant that the starboard shaft no longer turned, While we had been able to cross-connect No. 2 fire room onto both engine rooms and divide the steam between them to keep 17-1/2 knots, we now had to cut No. 2 fire room back on to No. 2 engine room and it turned over only on the port propeller. You know what it means with only your port screw turning over; your ship tends to go to starboard. We had to carry about twenty-five degrees of left rudder to steer a straight course. All of that friction slowed us down from 17-1/2 knots to 13-1/2 knots--we lost four more knots from having to carry that rudder to steer a straight course. If we were a "sitting duck" before, we were really one now.

Some Jap destroyers were moving down through the middle of the formation by this time and took us under fire. A shell, either a 5-inch or an 8-inch, hit right between two of our 20-millimeter guns . We called them "sky guns." You see we called our 5-inch guns No. 1 and No. 2; our 40-millimeter guns we called 41 and 42, and the 20-millimeter guns we called Sky 1 to Sky 10--we had ten of them: odd numbers on the starboard side and even number on the port side. This battle was all on our port side. Sky-2 and sky-4 were forward of the bridge. Sky-6 and sky-8 were on pedestal mountings built up, one forward of the stack and one abaft of the stack, and sky-l0 and sky-9 were back on the fantail of the ship right near where the depth charges were located. One of those shells hit right in there between sky-6 and sky-8 and had a most disastrous effect on the personnel. Unfortunately, out of about eight or nine men stationed on those two 20-millimeter guns all but two of them were killed--they were all out of the engineer's force--and one of them died later on the life raft. Actually there was only one survivor out of those two guns.

Also a lot of shrapnel and flying particles--those things were really hot because of the explosion--flew up around the bridge. They came in and set fire to the flag bags on the port side. About that time fires began to break out all over the ship as well as there on the bridge. The signalmen who were back on the lower level by the flag bags got shrapnel in their arms and shoulders and necks. It came in and clanked-clanked all around inside the bridge, and practically all of us up there had minor shrapnel wounds in our legs. At the time, however, I don't think any of us knew that we had been hit other than possibly the signalman who had a wound on his shoulder or arm which could been seen. But those of us who got nicked in the legs couldn't see the cuts in our pants. Those wounds were just slight ones.

About that time we were given one of the nastiest blasts we had to take. Our gyro compass was gone and our radars were out. The men from CIC had left down there and had come up. My Executive Officer, Bob Roberts, was no longer any good in CIC and he had come to the bridge. Now we had a youngster on the wheel from Asheville, North Carolina, by the name of Gentry. He was a quartermaster. Gentry was dazed and shaken and I was trying to get him to steer by magnetic compass. Due to his injuries, he didn't seem to understand what I was telling him. So I said, "Mr. Roberts, will you please take the wheel and get this ship out on the heading that I am trying to get to." At that moment I was standing on the steps between the open bridge and the pilot house when it seemed as if the whole ship went out from under us. I came over in the corner of the pilot house, the forward starboard corner up against the chart desk. Mr. Roberts and Gentry and I were all tangled up there together. Gentry raised himself up; blood was running out of his mouth and one of his teeth had been broken off. I picked myself up and got back to the open bridge. It was actually an amusing and ludicrous sight, Jack--only it was terribly serious--to see all those talkers out there with their telephone headsets, a special big type of helmet that goes over the head, lying all over the grating trying to pick themselves up and the telephone wires so twisted that they looked like a bunch of worms in a fishing can. No one was seriously hurt up there. But the blast had been so severe that I could find only one man that wasn't knocked off his feet. He was a yeoman named Cronin. His battle station was on the engine order telegraph. He was in the wheel house standing up with one hand on each lever and that, of course, was why he didn't get knocked down. When we picked ourselves up we realized the ship was not moving. The blast was apparently caused by three or four 14- inch shells from the KONGO with high-capacity ammunition. Those shells would go off it they just hit a dirt embankment. If they had hit the side of a big battleship they wouldn't have hurt her much, but they just ripped us, a little fellow, to pieces.

"What was the thickness of your skin?"

About one-half inch steel plate--half-inch, three-eighths, something like that. It just ripped the ship wide open. The best way I can describe that hole in our port quarter is to put it the way one of my enlisted men described it. I was asking various survivors what kind of a hole it was and one of the men said, "Well, Captain, you know those great big semi-truck and trailers?"

I said, "Yes." "Well," he said, "you could have taken one sideways and shoved it in there." In other words, probably about fifty or sixty feet of our ship's side was just absolutely blown out.

"A whole broadside from--"

A battleship did it. To me, Jack, it's amazing that such a little ship could take so much punishment. It is a credit to the Bureau of Ships that designed her and a credit to the Brown Shipyard that built her. I don't yet know how she did it. The way the men took what they took--that' s a credit to the American sailor, the average blue jacket. But this ship, she really held up marvelously--hit by four 14-inch shells, twelve 8-inch and about four 5-inch; that's the number Mr. Gurnett, the First Lieutenant, estimated from his interviews with survivors.

At that time, with the ship lying inert in the water, I was confronted with one of the most difficult decisions I have ever had to face: to decide what the hell to do. Should I abandon ship or not? I looked around my ship, I could see dead and wounded men everywhere. The ship was hopelessly battered up. From where I stood it was obvious that she was mortally wounded. The engines were no longer in operation. I had no communication with the engineering department. She had what I estimated was about a seven to ten degree list to starboard. Then Mr. Gurnett arrived on the bridge looking rather haggard and covered with pulverized asbestos lagging. He told me some things I already knew and some I didn't know. Among other things he told me that both engine rooms were definitely knocked out. He also told me that we were settling by the stern, that he had measured the list and found it to be eleven degrees. And he recommended that we abandon ship.

I felt that I had two responsibilities, Jack. My first obligation was to fight the ship as long as she could effectively be fought; the other was to save the men who were still alive and not expose them unnecessarily when they were no longer capable of fighting back. I knew the ship couldn't move, The question was:

Could she fight? I sent Tom Stevenson, the Communicator, aft and I sent Jack Moore, the Supply Officer, forward to bring me the dope on the 5-inch guns. That was my main battery, the only battery worth a damn.

From the bridge forward, as far as I could see, the ship was as nice as the day she left the shipyard because the damage had been down below deck, but from the stack aft she was a pretty sorry looking sight. There were two 20-millimeter gun tubs, No. 6 and No. 8, with parts of bodies hanging out of them; and there was the deck of the deck house warped back like a piece of linoleum ripped up and from there on aft nothing but a yawning mass of blackened metal as the various thwart ships and fore and aft bulkheads had been twisted together and the deck ripped off where that gun had disappeared.

While I was waiting for the reports to come back, there occurred a couple of exciting little events. I was standing in the starboard wing of the bridge when I sighted the wake of a torpedo headed directly amidships, and I was certain that that torpedo was going to hit us. Of course, that would have caused a terrible explosion which would have broken the ship in half right then and there. It wouldn't necessarily have killed everybody, but it would have been a very bad explosion. So I grabbed a good hold on the edge of the bridge wing and yelled at the top of my voice, "Stand by for torpedo explosion." Then that thing passed under our keel without hitting us--it couldn't have gone under us by more than a foot.

Right at this point, Jack, I want to say something about being scared. Anybody who says that he didn't get scared in a situation like this is either a liar or a damn fool. The point is, though, that you didn't stay scared. I think just about everybody on our ship and probably on all the other ships in our unit was as scared as hell when the first salvo from the Jap fleet landed in our midst. But as soon as the splashes had settled back, practically everyone was over it; and from then on, for the most part, we were too busy just operating and fighting the ship to think about being scared. I don't believe many people were scared as we took the various hits. I can't even remember any conscious reaction to them other than being shaken and jarred, but I do remember seeing that torpedo coming. That scared me even more than the first salvo. I didn't have anything to do. There was a lull in the battle. The ship wasn't moving and we had no way to avoid the torpedo or to fight back. My heart dropped right down with the lower intestines, and I am sure that my voice must have been very high-pitched and cracked as I shouted the warning. As soon as it was over and reports started back to the bridge, we all forgot about being scared.

Just about that time the destroyer JOHNSTON came by us and I saw her for the last time. That picture is engraved in my memory. I can see her right now. She had taken a terrific beating. Her bridge was battered and had been abandoned. Her foremast, a steel tubular mast, coming up just abaft of the bridge superstructure, had been split from shellfire and then bent down over itself--you remember when we were kids in school how we made those paper Japanese lanterns by slotting them--well, the mast was just that way, doubled over on itself and dangling down with its radar swinging just like a pendulum on a clock. It gave me a hurt feeling to look at it. Her searchlights had been knocked off. One torpedo mount was gone and her No. 3 gun had completely disappeared. As she went by--she was limping along at a pretty slow speed--I saw her Captain. He was a very big man with coal black hair; his name was Evans. I had met him at some of those conferences. He was standing on the fantail conning his ship by calling down through an open scuttle hatch into the steering engine room. I can see him now. He was stripped to the waist and was covered with blood. His left hand was wrapped in a handkerchief. I heard later that three fingers had been completely shot off. I also heard that his right cheek had been practically shot away. That accounted, I suppose, for all the blood. As he went by--he wasn' t over one hundred feet from us as he passed us on our starboard side--he turned a little and waved his hand at me. That's the last I saw of him because the JOHNSTON was sunk, too, a few minutes after we were.

Did he survive?"

No, he got off the ship but he did not survive. He was never found and apparently died in the water. As a matter of fact, his exec had already been killed and Lieutenant Hagen, the Gunnery Officer, was the senior surviving officer on the ship.

About that time the two officers I had sent for information came back and reported on the condition of our guns. Jack Moore said, "Captain, No. 1 gun has forty-two rounds left, but the gun has been damaged to the point where the men can no longer train it"--turn it around left and right--"by hand because it's jammed too much and they have no power; so the gun is ineffective." Then Tom Stevenson came back and said, "Captain, I can't get to gun No. 2. The deck house is all torn up; there is a fire on the main deck, burning fuel oil and burning powder fragments; the depth charges have been ripped apart; the gun is lying there stationary, the barrel is cherry-red clear back into the mount. I can see no signs of life and the back end of the gun mount is blown out. I don't think the gun is capable of being fired."

Then I knew we couldn't fight any longer and I gave the order to abandon ship.

Now, Jack, that's about the hardest thing one ever has to do. You've been at sea and you know that a sailor loves his ship as well as his men and his own life. You have a love for your ship and it's difficult for you to abandon your ship because she seems to be a living thing. Besides, it's hard to order men to go out and jump into the water. We were out in the Philippine Deep, about seven miles deep--it was a pretty rugged place. It was like jumping out of the frying pan into the fire, but we knew the frying pan; we knew we were going to burn in there and we didn't know whether the fire would go out or not.

So we started to abandon ship. It was a serious situation.

Men were dead and dying and more men were going to die before we could get off that ship. Yet some very amusing things happened. They shouldn't seem funny and yet they can't help but be funny when you look back on them and detach yourself from the grimness of it all. In abandoning ship, of course, we had to carry out the destruction bill and so I gave orders to carry it out. Among other things we had to do was to wreck and destroy a lot of confidential gear, such as the sonar equipment and some of the radar equipment and things of that kind. Lieutenant Roberts and I were nearly killed right then and there through no intention of a couple of men. Cayo and another sonar man grabbed some sledge hammers and started beating up the sonar machine. Then they took the tommy gun which carried .45 slugs and started spraying it. They almost sprayed the Executive Officer and Gentry and me. Gentry, poor kid, was about half-conscious. He was punch drunk from the blow he had taken when we were all knocked down on the bridge. Well, he saw all the destruction going on around him--I guess he figured everybody was destroying stuff and he ought to destroy something, too--so he took a pair of 7x50 binoculars and beat the lenses out of them--though there was nothing confidential about them--and then he proceeded to beat the glass face out of the gyro repeater--and there was nothing particularly confidential about a gyro repeater. When he was through he had a very self-satisfied look on his face--like the cat that's eaten the canary and licked the cream pitcher--as though he had really done a good job. Then he went on his way to abandon ship.

Some of the destruction work was much more serious business. Mr. Stevenson, the Communications Officer, had to get rid of all the confidential and secret communication publications. In order to do that he had to go down a little scuttle hatch below decks in a ship that was sinking. We had a coxswain by the name of Shaeffer whose duty assignment in no way covered that particular job, but he volunteered to go with Mr. Stevenson and help do that work. For that he was decorated and given a citation. Another job in connection with abandoning ship was to find all the wounded and get them off the ship. This was the place where I felt that I had a specific personal responsibility.

I ducked down to my cabin and in the dark reached into a drawer and got a whole bunch of papers--all kinds of letters and personal things and everything else--as much as I could hold in my two hands. Up on the bridge Lieutenant Roberts and I started sifting through the papers and scattering them until we found a copy of our muster list and our watch quarter and station bill which had the dope on everyone aboard. Lieutenant Roberts put it in his hip pocket and carried it there all the time we were in the water. Afterwards he gave it back to me and somewhere I still have that muster list. It is difficult to read now, so water soaked and covered with fuel oil is it and so chewed are the edges.

Another amusing incident occurred at that time. I was up on the bridge and the Executive Officer was there also. By that time some of the men were starting to get into the water. So I said to Bob Roberts, "Now, Bob, I want you to go down to the main deck and hustle things a little bit, and then I want you to get into the water and be out there to supervise the men." He replied, "Captain, I'm not leaving until you leave. I don't want you to be a damn fool and get heroic and go down with the ship." I answered, "Now look, Bob, I'm not intending to go down with the ship. I don't know what will happen. We are still under fire. My duty is to stay here until the men get off, and I'm going to do that." And I added, "As soon as everybody else is off, if I'm still alive, you can rest assured that I'm getting off. I haven't any false sense of glory like those old German naval sea captains who put on their best uniforms and stood up on the bridge and went down with the ship. But I am going to wait until I get my men off." He still held back and then I said, "Bob, I don't want to get tough with you; you are my exec and my good friend but, remember, this is an order. I want a responsible senior officer to be with the survivors and I'm ordering you to leave the ship." "Well," said he, "if that's the way you put it, Captain, I'll go." I said, "That's just the way I'm putting it," and I added, "I trust I'll see you in the water, but in case I don't, Bob"--and I stuck out my hand--"it's been swell being with you. You've been a swell exec and I want you to know that." Then he said to me, "It's been wonderful serving with you, Captain, I hope you make it; I'm leaving you with reluctance." Then we shook hands. Looking back on that scene now it seems amusing, the way we went through it, but at the time it was dead serious. Then we did something that was foolish. Bob said, "As long as I'm going over the side I don't need this"--we both had .45s strapped on us with all the extra ammunition--so he started to unbuckle his .45 and he said, "I'm going to get rid of this." I said, "I'm taking mine off, too." It was in my way and it was heavy. We started to drop them on the deck, but no, we very ceremoniously picked them up, held the cartridge belt by one hand, and saying, "One--two--three, " we flung them clear off the ship's side. Then Bob left me to abandon ship.

I then went down to the after-part of the bridge and looked down the main deck. It gave me an awfully hurt and crushed feeling to see the men lying there wounded and dead and to see our ship, once as alive as the people on her, battered and lifeless. And while I was looking, I saw a man moving down there among all those bodies and I recognized him. It was Staubach, Chief Electrician's Mate. He was sitting at an incline, leaning back against the stack, in a pool of blood. I could see he was alive so I cupped my hands and yelled to a couple of boys down there, a couple of radar men and Cantrell, Chief Quartermaster--I remember he was down there--"Some of you men get up here on the boat deck and pick up Staubach; he's in bad shape." They came up for him and then I started down.

I thought that I should see what the condition was in CIC, so I went down there to see if the boys had destroyed the radars. There were no lights left in the ship and I tried to find a battle lantern. I found one but apparently the force of the concussion of those shocks had broken the filament in the light bulb. I got hold of a flashlight and it wouldn't work either, I finally reached in my pocket and took out my cigarette lighter and it lit and I looked around. As far as I could see the boys had beaten the radars up. Later I found out that they had missed one, but I didn't know it then. For some reason or other I stepped into my cabin. It was utterly dark. I had a big piece of plexiglass on my desk, and underneath it I had a lot of pictures of Harriet and the children. I lit my cigarette lighter--I still had my doubts that I was going to get out alive--and I took probably forty or fifty seconds and looked at the pictures of my family. Then I debated whether I should try to pick up my pipes or anything, and I decided, "The hell with them," and I went on the way as I was--in a pair of khaki trousers, a shirt, a baseball cap, and a pair of socks and loafers.

I went down to the main deck and found Mr. Gurnett, the First Lieutenant, and King, the Pharmacist's Mate, and Shaeffer, the Coxswain, and Lieutenant Stevenson, the Communications Officer, all down there with about six or eight wounded men. Staubach was still there, and he was crying. He was a man about thirty-five years old. I don't mean he was a weakling because he cried. He was paralyzed, and they were trying to get a life jacket on him and get him off the ship. He didn't know how badly he was hurt. It really made me sick at my stomach and sick at my heart when I saw him because from his backbone clear around on his left side all was gone. We ripped blue chambray shirts off six or eight dead men, wadded them up, and stuck them into his lung cavity and wrapped another shirt around him and tied him, but he didn't know the difference. He didn't want to get into the water. He was crying and he said to me, "Captain, do you think I'll live?" I knew he wouldn't live, but I didn't have the heart to tell him. So I said, "Oh sure, Staubach, get off the ship and we'll take care of you." He said, "I don't want to die, Captain. I've never seen my baby yet." About two weeks before he had received word that his wife had had a baby boy. That's one of the heartbreaking things of war--so many of them have to die. And it hurts you, your own people. I had known Staubach, Chief Electrician's Mate, and he was a fine man. Finally we got him into a life jacket and into the water. He actually lived for a while. He was on the life raft with me. It was about 9:30 that morning when we abandoned ship, and Staubach died about 11:30. How he lived those two hours the way he was shot up--he should have been dead before we ever got him off the ship--but it was just the will to live because he wanted to see his baby.

While the other men were working on the wounded, Mr. Gurnett and I started to check the ship and see whether we had found all the wounded. First we started out separately. There was a thwart ship passageway between the galley and the wardroom country and the main deck house, and I went across there. I couldn't see because steam was still coming up from the hatch in No. 1 fire room. Of course, I knew my way across the passageway, so I took a deep breath and put my hand over my nose so that I wouldn't breathe the steam and plowed through it, I knew just by the feel that I was coming to the hatch, so I raised my foot and stepped over the hatch coaming. Just as I put my right foot down, it rolled and bucked on me and I pulled my hand down. I was out in the broad daylight on the port side. I looked down and there I had my foot right in some poor radioman's face. It gave me a bad start. I knew the boy, and I felt badly. You hate to do that to the dead. Of all the men we lost, Jack, we identified positively only seventeen of them as dead aboard the ship. That boy and the one lying beside him were two that I positively identified because I knew them both. There wasn't any blood on them. Those kids had been blown from quite a way down the ship and had been killed by concussion. I don't think there was a whole bone in them. They were just lying there as placid and peaceful as could be.

I went on down the deck. Now what affects one man and what affects another man be very different. The ship had been a very live thing--the ship herself and the men on her. Now she was a battered piece of junk. Nothing about the ship portrayed her condition as much as the view I had when I turned from looking at those boys and saw our motor whaleboat hanging in the davits with the boat gripes having been shot away--shrapnel had come and ripped the bottom of the boat out and the boat gripes away--so that she was dangling. She was still two-blocked up there at the davited heads, but she was dangling nevertheless. The sea painter was gone, and I could look from the deck up through the bottom of the boat. It was a sight I'll never forget. That one picture summed up the whole desolate destruction of a living ship with living men coming into an emptiness of nothing. I realized I was the only person alive on that side of the ship. A feeling of utter loneliness came over me. It made me shudder to look up through the bottom of that whaleboat with the swell of the sea rolling back over me. I could look out through her. Down on the deck there lay three men, two of whom I could identify and one I couldn't. They were dead.

I started on aft to see whether I could find any more men, and you know I was so upset that I wasn't watching where I was going. The next thing I knew I was sitting right on the deck. My two hands went down as I lit. I picked them up and they were covered with blood. Then I felt blood dripping on me. I looked up I was right under No. 6 gun tub, and I saw a man hanging over with his head shot off. Drip, drip, drip. There was a big puddle. I got up and found the seat of my pants soaking wet and my shoes wet with blood. I went on down the deck, and frankly at that moment I didn't care what happened. It had taken all the heart out of me. As I walked down toward the fantail I was nearly drowned because when I got back to where the three 14-inch shells had ripped into us and taken the side out, the main deck was gone from there on and I just barely caught myself from dropping right off into the water.

Well, I made my way back. Then Mr. Gurnett and I did some more checking on the ship. We were going down in the passageway, feeling along because it was dark; and there, hanging half way through the door to the yeoman's office, we found a man whom we recognized as Smith. He had dragged himself in there. We picked him up and dragged him out. For a while we couldn't figure out who he was. He must have had 2000 shrapnel holes in his face. When we touched him the blood would ooze out like water from a sponge. We raised his eyelids but he was blind in both eyes. He was unconscious. His eyeballs, his iris, and his pupils had been penetrated by fine shrapnel. How he ever got up there we'll never know, but he was still alive though barely so.

By that time we had checked over all the men and we had found every survivor we could possibly find. The ship was getting well down by the stern. The communications publications were gone. So I said to the boys, "Well, we better get off here."

"Was the firing still--"

Oh, yes, they were still shooting at us.

"Dead in the water and they couldn't hit you?"

They were hitting us every so often, but they knew we were finished. Just one destroyer off a way was more or less lazily tossing a few 5-inch shells at us. We took four hits during the process of abandoning ship. I know of six or eight men who were killed while the ship was being abandoned. At that time the only ones left alive on board, so far as we knew, were Lieutenant Stevenson, Lieutenant Gurnett, Pharmacist's Mate King, Coxswain Shaeffer, and myself, plus Smith who they were still trying to get into a life jacket. He was unconscious and, of course, didn't know where he was. I said to King and Shaeffer, "Let's get Smith into his life jacket and get going."

Now, Jack, at this point I must tell you the rest of the story about the crew of gun No. 2. It's not much to my liking. Goheen had to go across a deck covered with burning oil. He went into the gun mount and found a very pathetic condition there. A lot of the men had been completely obliterated. You see what had happened, Jack, was this: the gun had probably fired--oh, I would say, roughly--300 rounds when, because of hits, it no longer had any power ramming so the men had to ram by hand. Then at the last seven or eight shots the air injection system went out, and the gun was so hot that apparently the 324th round cooked off before the automatic breech was completely closed, blew the breech off the gun and the rear end out of the gun mount, and killed most of the men. When Goheen got in there he found Carr, who was ripped clear from his neck to his groin. He had an eighty-four pound projectile in his arms and begged Goheen to help him load it and get it off. He didn't realized that the gun was incapable of firing, and he was still so devoted to duty that he wanted to load that gun. Goheen took it away from him and laid him down and then picked up Gregory, the gun trainer, who was lying there with his right leg blown off almost up to his hip. He carried Gregory out and set him down on deck and then went back. Carr had gotten that shell again and was trying to load it. Goheen picked Carr up and carried him out. He died there on deck. Carr really spark-plugged the No. 2 gun crew, and we recommended him for a posthumous award of the Navy Cross.

A boy named Stansbury, who was the first loader on that gun, did a wonderful job and we recommended him for a silver star. Another fine man killed on that gun was Shirley Macon from Salem, Oregon. He was a chief gunner's mate who came out of Repair 2 and had gone down into the upper handling room of the gun right below the gun mount and was helping to get the ammunition up to them because the passers had passed out down there--Macon was killed by the force of that explosion down below. So much for the men on gun-2 and may peace be with them always.

When we got into battle our little mascot, Sammy, took it pretty hard. I felt sorry for him. He was running up and down the deck with all the guns firing and the men he knew lying dead in blood and gore. He actually went off his beam and shortly after going overboard drowned.

Keefe, a seaman, had had his own rubber life belt torn by shrapnel. When he was looking around for another one, he found Sammy's life jacket up on the fo'c'sle. He put it on, shoved it over one arm up to the shoulder. It gave just enough buoyancy for him to be able to swim and get to the life raft. It was a little thing but Keefe probably owes his life to Sammy's life jacket.

Now, to go back to the ship: Tom Stevenson got ready the last bag of communications, the least dangerous of the confidential communications on board--those that would matter the least if they were compromised. He took an ordinary seabag--we had no weights for it--and we picked up a couple of spanner wrenches, dumped them in, and a few odds and ends of pieces of metal. Steve allowed he would tie the bag on to him and swim with it until it got water soaked enough to sink. So Steve jumped into the water and Shaeffer lowered the seabag of publications down to him.

Finally Lieutenant Gurnett and I went forward up to the eyes of the ship, right up to the very bow. It was about twenty-five feet to the water because the bow was starting to come up. It was a good thing we went up there because we were able to spot a life raft more quickly than some of the men who left the ship fifteen minutes before we did because we knew where we were going.

"Was this life raft one of yours?"

Yes, one of ours. Then we jumped. Next King came into the water and Shaeffer lowered Smith down to him with a rope tied to his life jacket. Then Shaeffer jumped in. He was the last man to get off.



Forward to Chapter 8

Return to Articles Page

Return to Menu Page


Honor the Missing in Action and Killed in Action of Taffy III

We do remember.  We won't forget.


Robert Jon Cox - Webmaster - [email protected]
last revised September 28 1997
Copyright 1997 all rights reserved
Void where prohibited.