The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 12] MORAL CLAIMS OF THE OLIGARCH. 39

seemed to the oligarch an unanswerable argument for his permanent exclusion from privilege*. Even to-day the ability at need to serve in the army is regarded by many as an essential condition of political enfranchise­ment4, and in the city state of Greece, which was ever prepared for war, there was even stronger reason for such a provision6. But though the argument might be used against the poor, we must not forget that the ordinary oligarchy excluded from power many men who served as hoplites, and it was only in the polity that the qualification was sufficiently low to admit this class.

§ 12. Moral claims of the Oligarch.

The oligarch based his claim on other grounds. He argued, in effect, not only that he had a better right, than the poor man, to govern the state, but that he was better qualified to do so; while other classes were disqualified, alike physically and morally, from discharging political duties. I have pointed out that the oligarch assumed a moral and mental superiority, and there were, of course, elements of culture to which only the rich man could

3 The satirical pamphlet on the Athenian Constitution practically assumes that public service should mean political power, and the author explains that the principle is really recognised at Athens, for the stj/ji.os are the source of the city's power more than the yewatoi and jrXo&rioi and 6ir\?Tcu ([Xen.] Eesp. Ath. 1 2).

* We may compare the conscription. The inability to serve furnishes a common argument against the enfranchisement of women.

5 Cf. Freeman, Comparative Politics, p. 197 'In all primitive societies the distinction between soldier and civilian is unknown. Hence the army is the assembly, the assembly is the army.' Cf. the same author Sicily ii p. 62 where he argues (from Diod. xii 19) that it was originally the custom to wear arms in the assembly as a badge of citizenship.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

38

39

40
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW