The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

40 CHARACTER OF OLIGARCHY. [CH. I.

attain1: but the great advantage (according to the ideas of the Greeks) possessed by the man of property lay in his having leisure to practise the arts of war and of govern­ment, while the poor man not only lacked leisure, but was obliged to follow employments, which were disqualifying and degrading to body and mind. This subject is so intimately connected with the attitude of the Greeks to industry and commerce that we must briefly consider it.

In this matter we must distinguish the sentiment of the old military aristocracies from that of the commercial oligarchies. It has been suggested that the origin of the contemptuous feeling for industry and trade should be traced to the age of the migrations when the victorious invaders possessed themselves of the best land and left menial occupations to the subject-races8. Hence a general characteristic of the old military aristocracies was a definite division of classes, which resulted in the practical exclusion of the artisan and trader from the government. Some states actually made ' money-making' a disqualification, or forbade the ' banausic' arts to their citizens; an aris­tocracy, according to Aristotle, would render it impossible for the labourer or mechanic or trader to be a citizen*;

1 Cf. Ar. Pol. vi 8 1293 b 37 rt> fia\\ov a.Ko\ov9£v iraiSetav Kal etytveiav rmf finropurfpots.

2 Cf. Biichsenschutz, Besitz und Erwerb pp. 255 fi. See also Goll, Kulturbilder3 pp. 162 ft. and Newman, Introduction pp. 98 S.

3 Ar. Pol. iii 5 1278 a 19 'In an aristocratic state, in which power is given /tor" afKrty and ko.t' d|ia^,the /Sdi/awros and the 0-ijs cannot be citizens,' 01) yap oldv t' ^7riT7)5cO<rcu to tt;s dperTjs fuvra jilov fiavavaov $ $7771x61'. Cf. viii 12 1316 b 2 (v TroXXeus re oXi-yapx'a's ovk ?£e<tti xpw""ifecr0ai. Xen. Oec. 4 3 ^c ^Wais p.^v t&v 7r6Xewp, judXurTa 5£ tv tcus euTroX^uoiS 5o/coiVais elicit, o{iS' l^eim t&v iroXiTuii' oCSev! jSavaucri/cas t^x"^ epydfeffBai. Cf. Hdt. ii 167. For the few known particular instances of this prohibition see ch. v§50.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

39

40

41
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW