Scanned text contains errors.
38 CHARACTER OF OLIGARCHY. [CH. I.
§11. Material claims of the Oligarch.
This self-laudation, while it throws some light on the mental attitude of the oligarchs, has little bearing on their claims to rule. Their claims were both material and moral. On the former they assumed that they were better qualified to serve the state both in person and property, and, to invert the modern apophthegm, they might argue that property has its rights as well as its duties. We know that in Athens the burden of taxation was mostly borne by the rich, and we may conclude that in the oligarchies also the rich were the chief contributors to the revenue of the state1. We have only to consider the enormous influence which phrases like ' taxation and representation* have wielded in the modern world to realise that to the oligarch this fact would seem to constitute an indefeasible right to rule, and there are many instances in which we find the claim asserted*.
The rich man served the state also in person as a hoplite, while the poor man fought, not at all or only as a light-armed soldier; and the fact that the poor were thus unable to protect their fatherland in war, must have
1 In Ar. Pol. vi 4 '1291 a 33 ol eOropoi are defined as rii t<us oinrlius \ctTovpyovr.
2 Good instances occur in connection with the establishment of the Four Hundred. Thus it was proposed to entrust power toi/tois ot ar /tdXicrra rots re -j(fff]iiaffi. Ka.1 rots aa\ua.aai ii0eXei>' olol re <Lmv (Thuc. viii 65: cf. Ar. Ath. Pol. 29). The conspirators were ready {(r^peiv in rCiv ISiav otxijiv irpo0iV<Js...u? o$k£ti AXXots fj wpitriv aiJrots raXcuirupouyras (Thuc. viii 63). The claim is very prominent in the speech of the Boeotians (Thuc. iii 65); they argue that a minority of rich men, having a greater stake in the city (irXeiu ira/xi/SaXXA^oi) had a right to betray it in order to. 2£ia txfit. Cf. Ar. Pol. iii 12 1283 a 31.