The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 10] THE CHARACTER OF OLIGARCHY. 37

other differences. In early days, they might argue, power •was entrusted to ' the few,' and in every state ' the few' are ' wiser' and ' better' than ' the many': ' the wise' and ' the good ' are intended by nature to govern ' the base' and ' the mean.' There is of course the fatal fallacy underlying this theory, that it assumes that the few rich are identical with the few wise; but it is typical of oligarchic sentiment and it colours all oligarchic literature, although it was rejected and reversed by the democrats8.

2 I am obliged to omit from consideration the most interesting question of the political sentiment of Greek literature: but without touching on details, a few general points may be noted. The early writers with the exception of Hesiod took an aristocratic standpoint; and after political change had begun they remained the champions of aristocracy, opposed alike to tyranny, the rule of the many and the rule of wealth. (Of. Solon, Theognis and Alcaeus.) After democracy and oligarchy had become the prevalent forms of government, the oligarch tried to assert the same claim as the aristocrat; and just as he used ApufToKparla to denote 6\iyapxla so he was inclined to identify the few with oi xaXol Kdya.8ol, oi x/njoroJ, o! Svvarot, the many with ol rovripoi, ol /wxftiipol and the like: and to credit himself with evvonia, <ru<t>pomivr) etc. and his opponents with 0/3/xj and other evil qualities. Some of these terms almost lost their moral meaning and became simply party catch­words ; but the democrats used many of them with an absolutely opposite application, hurling back on the oligarchs the very terms of abuse applied to themselves and using every epithet of praise to describe democracy (see above § 1 n. 5). If .we consider the writers, who were neither oligarchs nor democrats by sympathy (such as Thucydides, Plato, and Aristotle), we find that they have censure enough for democracy. 'History is a sound aristocrat,' and most of these writers, living in Athens, must have been keenly alive to the faults of democracy: but History is no oligarch, and it would not be difficult to show that Greek literature is even less in sympathy with oligarchy than it is with de­mocracy.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

36

37

38
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW