Scanned text contains errors.
36 CHARACTER OF OLIGARCHY. [CH. I.
the aristocrat, maintained that only a part of the community was qualified for political duties or justified in exercising political power. They adopted the hypothesis that certain classes which might be qualified by birth and wealth, or birth and training, or by wealth alone, were fit to rule over others, who were not fit to rule. As long as aristocracy lasted, the authority of the rulers was not questioned. They were separated from their subjects by ineradicable class divisions: their rule was consecrated by prescription and they alone knew the secrets of government. In such a society, as long as the position of the rulers is not challenged, their sovereignty needs no explanation; it would be impossible to imagine any other distribution of power1.
But in course of time other social forces became dominant: the basis of privilege was widened; wealth took the place of birth, and the oligarch regarded himself as the heir of the aristocrat and asserted in virtue of his property an exclusive claim to rule. His claim did not go unchallenged. Aristocracy had been hedged by a divinity that prevented assault; it survived because it was not assaulted. But oligarchy rose on the downfall of aristocracy: it had won its position by force and by force it must maintain it or lose it. The ' age of discussion' began with the first break-up of the old governments, and henceforth constitutions had to struggle for existence. What then was the justification of oligarchy ? The oligarchs reasserted the claims of the aristocrats. In wealth and in the power that it gives they were on the same level, and they were not concerned to recognise 1 On the early aristocracies and the transition to oligarchy, see ch. ii § 24.