Scanned text contains errors.
32 CHARACTER OF OLIGARCHY. [CH. L
by Montesquieu. ' There are always persons,' he says, ' distinguished by their birth, riches, or honours: but were they to be confounded with the common people and have only the weight of a single vote, like the rest, the common liberty would be their slavery and they would have no interest in supporting it....The share they have, therefore, in the legislature, ought to be proportioned to their other advantages in the state6.'
The three qualities, which claim equality of privilege, are freedom, wealth and virtue (of which the two latter in combination include the idea of good birth7). But good birth and virtue are rare, and therefore democracy and oligarchy are the common types of constitution8; and the issue is limited to the rival claims of freedom and wealth. The democrats from being equal in respect of freedom regard themselves as entitled to absolute equality: the oligarchs from being unequal in the matter of property regard themselves as generally unequal and therefore seek to have an advantage in the state9. The contest thus lies between those who claim general equality and those who claim general inequality; in other words between the greater number and the greater property10.
The demands of oligarchy and democracy were irreconcilable : each asserted an indefeasible right to power:
6 Esprit des Lois Book xi c. 6. This corresponds to Aristotle's theory of political justice. Cf. Ar. Pol. viii 3 1303b 6 <rra<r«ifovoit...A' reus st^w-Kparfcus oi yvupi/MH., Sn inrtxoviK. tv* t<ruv oik iVoi 6Wes.
? Pol. vi 8 1294 a 19.
8 Pol. viii 1 1301 b 39.
» Pol. viii 1 1301 a 29.
10 Pol. vii 3 1318 a 18 <pa<ri ylap oi ori/tartKoi rovro Sixaiov S ri &v &6£y to?! irXeWiv oi S' 6\iyapxuioi S n &v S6£y ttj rXdovi ofatf...(xft S' a/uptrrcpa