Scanned text contains errors.
§ 9] THE CHARACTER OF DEMOCRACY. 33
and to the impossibility of compromising the dispute we may trace the bitterness and permanence of party strife throughout Greek history.
§ 9. The character of Democracy.
It will scarcely be possible to form a just idea of oligarchic sentiment without briefly considering the theory of the democrats, which was rejected so vehemently by the oligarchs. Democracy rested on the two principles of ' liberty' and ' equality1.' Liberty has been explained to mean free birth (the respect in which all citizens of a democracy were equal)2. But the term was used to denote a great deal more than that. It implies above all the right of the free man to have his voice in the control of the state, to be free from subjection to a superior class: in fact the self-government of the many3. At the same time it includes the greater measure of individual freedom and independence from restraint, which distinguished the Greek democracies from other constitutions4.
1 Pol. vi 4 1291 b 34 (t\ev9epla xal laar^). Cf. Thuc. ii 37 (to Ivav... (\ev8tpus iroXiTtiio^ev); Dem. xxi 67.
2 Newman, Introduction p. 248 n. 1.
3 The definition I give in the text is borne out by Aristotle, Pol. vii 2 1317 b 2 {\ev0tplas Si tv /dv to iv p^pti. &pxfa6aj. Kul Apxew, ib. 11 ?>> 5i to ffiv <is jSotfXerai tis. "EXevtfepla. frequently means 'self-government of the people,' while SouXeio denotes subjection to a ruling class. Cf. [Xen.] Keep. Ath. 196 J^/ios ov fto6\erai....Sou\eiei.v ( = be subjects of an oligarchy) dXX' eXetiflepos efroi Ka.1 apxc-". Contrast ib. 3 11. Cf. Thuc. viii 68 4 (where i\ev8fpk = self-government) and contrast iv 85; vi 40 2; Xen. Hell, ii 3 24; Plato Rep. v 463 a b.
4 Cf. Aristotle quoted in n. 3 and Pol. viii 9 1310 a 30 (W«t) i\cM>epov Kal laov ri> on av poAXirral ns iroieiK. Plato Rep. viii 562 lays stress on the excess of liberty in democracies. Cf. Thuc. ii 39; vii 69 (17 fv avr-g dvfri-raxTot irSuru> (t t^v otaiTav i£ov<rta); Dem. xxv 25. Cf. § 12 n. 17.
w. 3