The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 8] THE BASIS OF OLIGARCHY AND DEMOCHACY. 31

more narrow the circle of the governors. Analogous to this government but on a more equitable basis was the polity, a constitution resembling oligarchy in the exclusion of the poor and in the privilege ascribed to property, but differing from it in the low census required and the pro­portionately larger number included within *the citizen body.

§ 8. The bctsis of Oligarchy and Democracy.

All constitutions, according to Aristotle, are based on some principle of justice or equality1; in other words there must be in the governing body some qualification, which forms the basis of privilege, some one respect in which all citizens, qiui citizens, are equal2. The democrat claimed that all the freemen of the state were equal: he, therefore, based his claim on ' freedom*.' Equality, how­ever, is not a mere question of number: states are based on 'qualities,' as well as 'quantity*'; and there is as much injustice in giving equality of privilege to unequals, as in denying it to equals5. The truth is well expressed

1 Pol. viii 1 1301 a 26.

a Pol. vi 11 1295 b 25 /SotfXerai 5{ ye ij iroXis tl- l<ruv efoai /cal ofiaLwv on /ulXttrra. Cf. Isocr. iii 15 at b\iya.pxlvu- koj, dip^uoKparicu rds iffbTTjras rots litrtxmiai twv iroXiTeiuiv {tyrowri, Kal tout' eWo/a/uei Trap' avrcus, rpi iiytitv trtpos trfpov Stirrirai ir\4ov txciv.

3 See below § 9.

4 Pol. vi 12 1296 b 16 fan 8t ireura iriXis ik rt tou roiov /tot ircxroC: t'6. viii 1 1301 b 29 <?<m Si Sirrov to tvw rb /lev yap api0/Mf to Si ko.t' dlioy ivrl*.

1 Pol. iii 9 1280 a 11 Soxei t<rov t& Stxaiov elvai xal t<rnv dXX" 06 ir<uru> dXXd tois fooi5. Cf. Plato Rep. viii 558 c (of democracy) iffonrrd too epolu! tffoa re xal dvtaois Siavepificvoi. Cf. Isocr. iii 14 SucaiiraToc t^.../oi rote Avofiolovs twv

Pages
About | Contents | Index

30

31

32
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW