The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 6] ARISTOCBACY. 25

use and was too convenient to be renounced, and Aristotle himself applies it to actual as well as to ideal constitutions. The normal government of the few he calls Aristocracy4, thereby putting it on a level with monarchy and polity: the rule of the nobles in early Greece is similarly de­scribed6, and there are passages enough in the Politics to show that there were governments existing in his own day, to which Aristotle would not deny the title*.

Aristocracy, however, is usually defined by Greek writers in moral terms, so that it is difficult to reduce it to ordinary principles of classification. As the normal form of the government of the few, it differs from oligarchy in the political qualification. In place of wealth, the quali­fication of the oligarchy proper, 'virtue' or 'merit7' or 'education8' is substituted, and the ruling class is described as 'the best9,' 'the good10,' 'the wisest11' or 'the men of worth12.' Any process of selection which tended to assign

* Pol. iii 7 1279 a 34 (he there shows that he is following popular usage—KaXel*' eltbdafitv).

5 The use of the title is implied in Pol. iii 15 1286 b.

6 Aristocracies are spoken of as actual constitutions frequently in the sixth and eighth books. Of. for example viii 8 1308 a 3.

7 Pol. vi 8 1294 a 10 apur-roKparia.^ Spas aper-f). It is defined again and again as the government ko.t' Apfrijv or /car' d£tap. (See Politics passim and Ethics I.e.)

8 On TratSela see below, nn. 25—28.

9 Pol. iii 7 1279 a 34 (where another definition is suggested): cf. Hdt. iii 81.

10 Pol. iii 15 1286 b 4.

11 Polybius vi ens. 3—10 defines aristocracy as the government ad­ministered tur6 run SiKaiordruv xai <f>povi]j.(j>T&TUv (car' en\o~ft)ti.

12 eVtcuceit (a word constantly used in this connection by Aristotle, cf. Pol. iii 10 1281 a 28; 12 1283 a 16) is difficult to translate, as it seems to combine a moral sense (fair, reasonable) with a social application (respectable, decent).

Pages
About | Contents | Index

24

25

26
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW