Scanned text contains errors.
24 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
be so moderate, that Aristotle would refuse to include the constitution under the term oligarchy10, but unless we accept his definition absolutely, we cannot omit from consideration a government analogous in every way to oligarchy, based upon the same kind of qualification and differing from it solely in degree.
Of governments ba^ed upon wealth there must have been many gradations from the moderate polity, in which perhaps almost half the freemen ruled, to the extreme, narrow oligarchy, in which a few men, concentrating all power in their own hands, controlled the government in their own interest.
§ 6. Aristocracy.
The inconsistency and confusion of Greek political terminology is illustrated by the use of the title Aristocracy. While popular usage made it a mere equivalent for oligarchy1, the philosophers chose the term to describe the ideal state2, the only constitution, according to Aristotle, justly entitled to the name8. But it was in general
10 He seems to have considered a high census essential to oligarchy. Thus in Pol. vi 11 1296 a 14 he tells us that the moderately wealthy citizens are found in greater numbers in democracies than in oligarchies. Cf. iii 5 1278a 22 & 5e tcus t>\iya,p-xiaj.s...&irb ri/uij/idTWi/ /ia.Kpuv ai /itS^eit twc dpx<*>"- See above § 4 n. 5.
1 See above§ 3n. 11.
a Plato Rep. iv 445 d applies the term apLeroKparia. to the ideal state, reserving ri/uoicpa-rfa (viii 547 d) to describe the better type of oligarchy •which in the Politicus (301 a) is called dpiffToxparia. Aristotle uses dpurroKparla for the best state, but he is not consistent.
* Pol. vi 7 1293 b 3 tt\v yap (k twv aptaruv dirXuis TroXirefoc ko.t' aptrriv kcu fi^i Trpos ifv60€ffiv Tiva ayo,6wv foSpCw iuavr\v SiKtuov irpoffayopcticw dpurro-Kpariav.