Scanned text contains errors.
26 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
power in accordance with merit was said to be aristocratic1', and some constitutions, which in other respects might be regarded as oligarchies or democracies, by the exercise of this principle acquired an aristocratic element".
If we accept the definition in a purely moral sense it is obvious that the term aristocracy can only have an ideal application. Virtue in the abstract can only be made the test of citizenship in Utopia ; in the world of facts there is no infallible means of excluding the base and worthless. In a political connexion virtue must bear a relative and conventional sense, and I proceed to enquire what formal tests can be applied to define the actual aristocracy. The virtue of the citizen, as Aristotle says, is relative to the state16; and the term may be used in a conventional sense to denote the qualities, which may be predicated of a ruling class18. In this sense it is the attribute of power, and the qualities implied are generally the qualities of the warrior and the ruler. Considered historically these were found in the early constitutions only in certain
13 Pol. vi 7 1293 b 10 Sirov ye ipiffTivSr)i> aipovvrcu ris apxas Tro\tTela apurTOKpaTutT] KoXeirai ; of. ii 11 1273 a 25. The election' of archons described in Ar. Ath. Pol. 8 2 (cf. Philoch. 58, F. H. G. i 394) was aristocratic and the process of SoKtfuurta was, in intention, aristocratic.
14 Cf. Pol. viii 7 1307 a. The Solonian democracy was regarded as having an aristocratic character (Isocr. xii 131) : Pericles claims the same character for the fully developed democracy (Thuc. ii 37 ?Ka<rros...djr'
15 Pol. iii 3 1276 b 30 ttjv aperriv ava^Katov elvai rov TroXfrov irpia tt^v TroXiTfiav. Cf. vi 7 1293 b 6.
16 It is obvious that apery is used in a restricted sense ; Aristotle (Pol. iii 12 1283 a 20) mentions 5iKau.wtivri and TroXe^iiio; &pctt) as the attributes of the oriei/ceis (the ruling class of an aristocracy). Xen. Resp. Lac. 10 7 alludes to ttoxitikt; dperij. So Montesquieu (Preface to Esprit des Loii) uses virtue in an absolutely arbitrary sense.