The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 3] OLIGARCHY IN A GENERAL SENSE. 19

who were serfs, but over the Perioeci who were subject but not enslaved. - Greek writers, in their general ignorance of Lacedaemonian institutions, formed different concep­tions of the constitution. Some excluded the Perioeci, others took them into account18. Aristotle tells us that many wished to.call the government a democracy, others an oligarchy": it was said to be compounded of oligarchy, monarchy and democracy", and he defines it himself as a mixture of aristocratic and democratic elements18. Isocrates in the Panathenaicus defines the constitution of Lycurgus as democracy mixed with aristocracylt; but in another treatise he says that the Lacedaemonians were governed by an oligarchy80. The uncertainty and inconsistency of the Greek writers leaves us to form our own definition, and in the light of present knowledge we conclude that the Spartan constitution, so peculiarly compounded of .diverse elements as to evade exact definition, must alike from the form of its institutions, the spirit of its ad­ministration, and the exercise of sovereign power, be included among the oligarchies of Greece. It is distin­guished more particularly below as an aristocracy21.

15 Isoorates xii 178 calls the perioeci Sij/Hos, as if they were part of a Spartan oligarchy. Aristotle on the other hand (Pol. ii 6 1270 b 18) confines this term to the Spartiatea.

16 Pol. vi 7 1294 b 19.

v Ib. ii 6 1265 b 35.

18 Ib. vi 7 1293 b 16; of. ii 9 1270 b 16 (owing to the power of the Ephors) 5rnj.oKpa.rta (£ o^toTOKpaTlaj <r\mtfl<uv&>; Plato, Laws iv 712 D. In Pol. viii 7 1307 a 34 and 12 1316 a 33 Aristotle describes the Spartan constitution as an aristocracy.

18 xii 153; cf. vii 61, xii 178.

20 iii24.

21 See §§ 6 and 32.

2—2

Pages
About | Contents | Index

18

19

20
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW