The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

20 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.

| 4. Oligarchy in a special sense.

I proceed to the more precise definition of the ' Govern­ment of the few.' Oligarchy in general includes both oligarchy in a special sense and aristocracy, while polity, although classed by Aristotle with democracies, sometimes denoted the government of a minority, and must not, therefore, be omitted from consideration.

Aristotle recognises that oligarchy is distinguished from democracy by other principles than those of number, and at the outset he corrects his definition by adding the test of poverty and wealth1. Any constitution, in which wealth confers the privileges of citizenship2, whether the rulers be few or many, must be regarded as an oligarchy*. He even argues that if a constitution existed in which a thousand wealthy men ruled over three hundred poor men, excluded from the rights of citizenship, no one would call it a democracy4. At the same time economic

1 The difficulty of including the idea of both number and wealth in the definition of oligarchy and democracy is discussed in Pol. iii 8 1279 b.

2 I use citizen throughout this essay in the strict sense given to the word by Aristotle, as one possessed of political privilege: roMnis S' AirXfit ovScfl twv dXXfcW 6p(feroi fM\\ov rj rf juer^x*"' <VX^S (Pol. iii 1 1275 a 22). Aristotle quotes other definitions, which he rejects. In iii 7 1279 a 31 he regards participation in the weal of the state as essential, but in iv 13 1322 a 33 he refers to ' citizens who share in the constitution' as if the title included others who were excluded. As he says (iii 1 1275 a 3) the citizen in a democracy would not be a citizen in an oligarchy. Whether the title would have been conferred on the unprivileged class in an oligarchy we do not know.

11 Pol. iii 8 1280 a 1 arayiauor otov av dpx&xri &4 rXovTov Sa> t' i\i,TTOvt, ir\eiovs, elvoi ra&rrp 6\iyi>.pxl<u>.

4 Pol. vi 4 1290 a 30; at the same time Aristotle (it. b 15), citing the

Pages
About | Contents | Index

19

20

21
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW