Scanned text contains errors.
18 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
'dynasty' was also employed in a general sense". The writers, however, who differentiated constitutions by their ethical qualities used aristocracy to denote the good form of the rule of the few and oligarchy to denote the bad, though even in this respect the usage was not consistent15.
Taking number only into account, we may define oligarchy as a form of government in which supreme power is held by a privileged class, small in proportion to the total number of free men in the state14. To complete our definition we must take into account the basis of privilege and of exclusion, a subject discussed in the following sections. The classification of Greek constitutions is complicated by the class divisions, which generally existed. The slaves or serfs may be omitted from consideration, but there existed in many states a class of free subjects, and this class we must regard in defining the character of a constitution. In so doing we may conflict with the usage of some Greek writers. The political theory of the Greeks was not clearly or consistently formulated, and we have a striking instance of the vagueness of Greek writers in their treatment of the Spartan constitution.
The Spartiates were a comparatively small part of the free population of Laconia, ruling not only over the Helots
18 Plato, Politicus 291 d. It generally denotes a narrow and absolute oligarchy.
13 Aristotle uses these terms in all three passages (quoted above). Plato, Politicus 301A also does so. In the Republic viii 545 c he uses Ttij.aKpa.Tia. to denote the first deviation from the ideal dpurroKpaTla. Xen. Mem. iv 6 12 denotes the ordinary oligarchy by irXouTo/c/xwia; Plutarch I.e. uses Svrturrela,.
14 Professor Freeman, Comparative Politics p. 194, defined oligarchy as the constitution 'in which political rights belong to only a part of those who enjoy civil rights'; he should at least have said a minority.