The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 3] OLIGARCHY IN A GENEEAL SEK8E. 17

complete that the same government may bear the name either of oligarchy or democracy7. There is, then, no sharp line of cleavage between oligarchies and democracies; and different opinions might be held about the definition of a particular constitution. For where governments are classi­fied according to the relative numbers of the ruling class and the entire community, some may regard as an oli­garchy what others will consider a democracy8, and Aristotle says that what in his day would have been called a polity, was in earlier times described as a demo­cracy*.

We must, therefore, arrive at a more precise definition of oligarchy. As the word implies, it originally denoted simply the government of the few, whatever the test was by which they were chosen from the many10. 'Aristocracy' was also used popularly to denote the same thing", and

7 Ar. Pol. vi 9 1294 b 14.

8 Cf. Austin, Jurisprudence Lect. vi.

8 Pol. vi 13 1297 b 24 St&irep as vvv KaXoD/ieK iroXirefas, oi irporepov ti«i\ow 8tj/ioKpar(as. A good instance is afforded by Syracuse. It is clear from Thucydides (vi 39) that he regarded the constitution in 415 as a democracy: Aristotle (Pol. viii 4 1304 a 2) describes it as a polity. The term iroXircia seems to have been in general use as a complimentary description of democracy. Cf. Ar. Eth. viii 12 1160 a 33 vo\iTtia.v avr^v oi irXeurrot KaXefr ; Harp. 8. v. IStus ft&8a.fft t<£ &vbpa.Ti xp?}<rdai oi ttjs Sijitoitparias; Dem. xv 20 ; Isocr. iv 125.

10 Hdt. iii 80 uses dXi-yapxb) of the government of the dpioroi. Ar. Pol. viii 1 1306 b 24 defines aristocracy as a sort of oligarchy: vi 3 1290 a 16 the popular definition included aristocracy under the title dXi-yapx'o- Plutarch I.e. uses A\iya/>x.ta. to denote the good form.

u Thrasymachus in Plato, Rep. i 338 d. Thuc. iii 82 says that apurro-Kparla. aufypuv was a party catchword of the oligarchs: but he himself uses aptoTo/cparfa in a general sense in viii 64. Cf. Xen. Hell, v 2 7 oi rat oifftat.. dpurroxparif (yfCMTo.

w. 2

Pages
About | Contents | Index

16

17

18
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW