The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

16 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.

no separate and independent basis of its own4.' In practice also this holds good; for kingship, which is denned as the government of willing subjects, requires the consent and support of a class of nobles. The rise of aristocracies in Greece involved the transfer of supreme power from the king to the nobles, but the king was in many states retained as the nominal head of the constitution5. Hence it comes that Aristotle, leaving out of view the monarchies in the semi-barbarous and backward states of Greece, regards kingship merely as a life magistracy6. No one would have thought of calling the Spartan constitution a kingship, because it had two hereditary generals who held office for life.

Classing kingship, therefore, with aristocracy and omitting tyranny from consideration we have only left the governments of the few and of the many: oligarchy and aristocracy on the one hand and democracy and polity on the other. Polity (which is discussed more fully below) denotes either a moderate popular government or a govern­ment of mixed oligarchic and democratic elements. It thus forms a link between oligarchy and democracy, and in some constitutions the fusion of these elements is so

4 Henkel, Studien zur Geschichte der griechischen Lehre verm Staat, p. 57. Cf. Austin, Jurisprudence Leot. vi. 'Limited monarchy is not monarchy. It is one or another of those infinite forms of aristocracy, which result from the infinite modes, wherein the sovereign number may share the sovereign power.' Aristotle ranks it with aristocracy (Pol. iii 16 1287 a 3 6 niv yap Kara vb/j.oi' \ey6/j.evos jSao-tXeiis oik tanv eJSos iroXi-relai; viii 10 1310 b 2 r) jSocriXefa ko.tcl ttjk tipuTTOKparlav (arlii) except in the ideal form of ira/u/ScunXefa (iii 14 1285 b 31).

' See §24.

6 Ar. Pol. iii 14 1285 a 6 affnj niv duv t\ jSaucXc/a otov arpa.T'rrtla rw Kal AlStos eirrlv.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

15

16

17
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW