Scanned text contains errors.
§ 3] OLIGARCHY IN A GENERAL SENSE. 15
a few men, or the multitude: and this element will either rule absolutely, without regard to law, without the participation of other elements in the government, or rule constitutionally, with due observance of law, under the influence of other elements. This classification was intended to apply only to the city-state, but though political conditions have changed, and nations have taken the place of cities as political units, modern political science has little or nothing to add to the definitions of Aristotle45.
§ 3. Oligarchy in a general sense.
For practical purposes any study of Greek constitutions may be limited to those included under the terms oligarchy and democracy, if we use the terms in a general sense without implying any ethical meaning. These, as Aristotle himself says, are the constitutions that generally prevailed1, and many of the Greeks roughly classified all governments as democracies or oligarchies2. Tyranny was not regarded as a constitution, but as a temporary interruption of legal rule3: kingship ' was in the whole political theory of antiquity only a form of aristocracy resting on
45 Bluntschli, The Theory of the State p. 311, accepts Aristotle's classification, but adds to it 'Ideocracy' and 'Idolooracy,' constitutions 'in which the supreme power has been attributed to some divine being or to an idea. The men who exercised power were regarded as the servants and vice-regents of an unseen ruler.' But whatever pretensions may have been put forward, power was actually wielded by one or more men. As Bluntschli says, both forma involve the rule of priests. We may fairly regard the governments as theocratic monarchies or aristocracies.
1 Pol. viii 11301 b 39 /j.i.\urTa Sto yivovrcu TroXireiai Sfj/j.os xa.1 6\iyapxla.
2 Cf. Ar. Pol. vi 3 1290 a 15 : popular classification recognised only oligarchy (including aristocracy) and democracy (including polity).
3 Ib. vi 8 1293 b 29 &A rt> rcuruv TJKurra •ra&n\v clvcu Tro\irflav.