Scanned text contains errors.
14 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
with the new democracy, and for a time a moderate form of government was maintained. Thus the Solonian constitution at Athens was described with universal approval"; and the same consideration will explain much of the admiration that was lavished on the institutions of Ly-curgus42. Thucydides departs from his usual attitude of absolute impartiality to praise the mixed constitution established at Athens in 41143; Plato made the ideal state of the Laws a mixture of democracy, oligarchy and aristocracy ; Aristotle devotes a large part of the sixth book to the discussion of mixed forms and argues for their greater justice and stability44.
This consideration need not cause us to enlarge our classification. Although some constitutions like that of Solon might involve so even a balance of diverse elements, that it would be difficult to define their character, we find in most governments some one social element predominant; and we are thus able to assign each to one of the ordinary classes.
To sum up; we may accept in the main Aristotle's classification. The ruling element will be one man, or
41 Cf. Ar. Pol. ii 12 1273 b 38; Isoor. xii 131 (Sri/Mxparla ipurroxparlf XpunivTl}, Plato, Laws iii 698 b.
42 The Spartan constitution was regarded as a combination of all other forms. See below § 3 nn. 15—20 and of. Isocr. xii 153 (SritwxpaTia. apiffToKpart^ fj^fuyfj^yij) j Polyb. vi 10 6.
43 viii 97 2.
« Pol. vi 8 1293b; ib. 9 1294a. Cf. ib. 12 1297a 7 fav 8' ZU tnea>or il iroXiTcia /ux^fi roaofrrif noviiuarlpa. Tacitus (Ann. iv 33) took an opposite view; 'cunctas nationes aut urbes populus aut primores aut singnli regunt: delecta ex his et consociata reipublicae forma laudari facilius quarn evenire, vel si evenit, baud diutuma esse potest.' Cf. Cic. At rep. i 29 45.