The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 2] CLASSIFICATION OF THE PHILOSOPHEBS. 13

This distinction had already been drawn by other writers*7, and serves to distinguish absolute forms of government from constitutional forms, observing equal laws88. Thus tyranny, extreme oligarchy and extreme democracy con­tain despotic elements, alien from the idea of law, while kingship and the more moderate forms of oligarchy and democracy (including aristocracy and ' polity ') are charac­terised by respect for law and justice".

Another test has to be considered before our classifi­cation is complete. A constitution might be mixed, might contain elements which were characteristic of more than one of the main types of government.

Such constitutions were warmly praised by the political philosophers. The general tendency of constitutional development in Greece was towards the intensification of oligarchy and democracy, and in the fourth century the extreme forms were found almost everywhere40. But in the gradual evolution of democracy the constitution passed through a stage in which the old aristocracy was tempered

(i.e. the interest of the ruler, not of the state). Plato, Rep. iv 433 A defines it as t& avrov Tpdrrtit xal firj To\vrpayfu>i>eui (i.e. the correct apportionment and performance of special functions).

37 Thuc. iii 62 contrasts dXryapx'0 Ifffoo/ua with Svrcurrela p.t) /mtcl vbfiuv. Cf. Xen. Mem. iv 6 12. NA/i<" and dro/ila. differentiate constitu­tions in Plato, Politic™ 291 a.

38 The distinction is made clear in Aristotle, Pol. vi 4 1292 a 32 trov •yip it^\ vA/toi Hpxovatv, oi>« lirn iroXtTefo. Set yap ria> it^f vl>iu>ti &px.eu> r&vruv, riai Si K0.0' fxaara rds ap^is icai rrjv ro\irflai> Kpivciv. In iii 4 1277 b 9 (dpx^ ToXiT«}|) and 8 1279 b 16 (dpx^ Searorucii) the two forms are de­scribed by the names usually employed.

89 Constitutions according to law are not necessarily normal. The basis of government may be bad, and the respect for law will then only distinguish degreei of perversion.

* See chapter ii § 27.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

12

13

14
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW