Scanned text contains errors.
12 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
on it. But the motive of the ruler scarcely offers a satisfactory criterion to determine varieties of constitutions. Montesquieu says of Aristotle's definition of monarchy ' he makes five species; and he does not distinguish them by the form of constitution, but by things merely accidental, as the virtues and vices of the prince; or by things extrinsic, such as tyranny usurped or inherited35.' We cannot tell a priori what ethical character a constitution possesses; governments must be classified in accordance with the form of their institutions, not the character of their rulers. Moreover the principle leads Aristotle into inconsistency33, and he himself seems to have realised its inadequacy, for in his detailed account of constitutions he applies formal, rather than moral, principles of classification84.
Aristotle supplies us with another test by defining the common advantage to be identical with justice35; and the normal states are those that pursue justice, the perversions those that disregard it. If we define justice with Mill as 'the impartial administration of law,' we arrive at the separation of states ruling with due observance of law from those which rule absolutely without regard for law36.
82 Esprit dee toil, Bk xi § 9.
83 Thus alffvfianjTfla; which was essentially a government for the common good, is classed by Aristotle, Pol. iii 14 1285 a 31, with rvpavvLi.
84 Thus iroXirefo (the 'normal' democracy) is defined, either as the government of those possessing arms, or as a constitution of mixed democratic and oligarchic elements. Even ApurToKparla can be brought within formal definitions. See below § 6.
85 Pol. iii 12 1282 b 17; ib. 13 1283 b 40. Thuc. and [Xen.] also identify them. See above n. 29.
36 Aristotle argues for the supremacy of law (Pol. iii 11 1282 b 2). Thrasymachus (in Plato, Rep. i 338 c) defines justice as to tov