Scanned text contains errors.
§ 2] CLASSIFICATION OF THE PHILOSOPHERS. 11
for their own advantage and govern absolutely: in the constitution properly so called they rule for the common good88. Of this distinction we find traces in earlier writers89. The distinction thus drawn between the personal interests of the rulers and the common interests of the state is of great importance. Kant traced the origin of the state ' to the antagonism resulting from the fact that men have both tendencies to social union and tendencies disruptive of it, both general sympathies and private interests30'; and the same contrast was noticed by Napoleon III. ' There exist,' he said, 'in every country two distinct and often contrary interests, general interests and individual interests —these may be denominated the permanent and the transient interests31.' The statesman has no harder problem than the reconciliation of particular claims with common advantage, and in a practical work on statesmanship, such as is the Politics, Aristotle was right to insist
28 Pol. iii 6 1279 a 17. In the Ethics I. c. this criterion is applied to monarchy (6 /je> yap ripavvos rb airrif aviupfpov SKoiref, o 5e /3acriXei>s to twv Apxofifruv) and suggested in the description of oligarchy.
29 Cf. Thuc. iii 82 ou l^XP1 T0" SiKaiov kou ry 7r6\« £v/j.<j>6pov TrporMvres, is Si to fnartpots irov del tioovt}v ?x°" oplfofres; [Xen.] Z>e Rep. Ath. 1 13 06 tov diKoiov oiyrots /xf*X«i /AaAAop tj tov avrots (rv/j.<p£povTos. The distinction is drawn by Plato in the dialogue between Socrates and Thrasymachus (Rep. i 338 d and 342 e). Cf. Laws iv 715s Ta.vTa.s...<pa.ficv...ovT' elvai ToAirefas our* 6p6oiis vftpovs, otrot ^ t-vpirdffiis ttjs ir^Xews eVe/ca tov KOivoG MStiaav. Cf. also Isocr. xii 132.
30 Quoted by Newman, Introduction p. 33.
81 See Des Idea Napoltoniennes (English Translation 1840) p. 21. Aristotle is not so precise in his definition, he does not distinguish the temporary and the permanent interests. ' He does not appear to note that the rule must be exercised not merely for the common advantage of the existing generation, but for the advantage also of the unborn of future generations.' (Newman, Introduction p. 252, n. 1.)