Scanned text contains errors.
10 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
Aristotle followed Plato in the division of constitutions into six main forms. In the Rhetoric and the Ethics the discussion of the subject is incidental and subordinate to the main topic, and we may accept the scheme in the Politics as representing the more accurate and the more mature thought of the philosopher; the definitions in the other works we need only discuss in so far as they differ. In the Rhetoric—the earliest of the three works—where he argues that the orator must take into account the Wi] teal vopifM of the constitution, he practically adopts the classification of Socrates as it is recorded by Xenophon". Besides the double forms of monarchy and oligarchy he only mentions one form of democracy and defines it somewhat arbitrarily as ' the government in which office is assigned by lot.' In the Ethics", where he discusses varieties of friendship, the six forms of government are mentioned with the titles they bear in the Polities'", but with slight variations in the definition. The principles of classification, finally adopted by him, lead him to distinguish three ' normal constitutions' and three ' perversions' or ' corruptions*7.'
The perversion is distinguished from the normal type by a difference of end. In the perversion the rulers rule
24 Bhet. i 8 1365. The definition of ApurroKpaTla corresponds to that given by Xenophon (Mem. iv 6 12). I discuss it below § 6.
28 viii 12 1160. The definition of jroXiTeia as rt/toicpcmio) differs from the definition of the Politics. See below § 5.
26 iii ehs. 6—9.
27 Cf. Eth. 1. c. To\iTftai $' fffriv etSri Tpla., ttrai Si Kal irapeic/Sdcras, otor QOopai toi/twk. The idea of the ' normal' and the ' perverted' constitutions had been already suggested by Plato, though ho regards all actual constitutions as perversions, in comparison with the ideal. Cf. Rep. v 449 a 6pff-r) iroXtrela and ^tapTTj/tA-cu; Polit. 302 B ; Laws iv 714 B.