Scanned text contains errors.
§ 2] CLASSIFICATION OF THE PHILOSOPHERS. 9
mixed aristocratic and democratic elements, but Plato cannot overcome his distrust of the people. He wishes to give the control of the government to a few wise men, and to leave to the multitude only such a semblance of power as shall soothe their discontent and prevent them from being dangerous.
Plato's description of actual constitutions in the Politi-cus is incidentally introduced to show how worthless they are in comparison with the rule of the perfect statesman. His enumeration is therefore intended to be complete, and it is certainly based on far more scientific principles than the classification in either of the other works. Starting with the criterion of number*0 he adds the ideas of force and consent (already mentioned in Xenophon's definition of monarchy21), of poverty and wealth28, of lawlessness and respect for law M. These principles serve to divide constitutions into kingship and tyranny, aristocracy and oligarchy, and the two forms of. democracy, both described by one name. Of these six governments monarchy and aristocracy have the first place, then come the two democracies, lastly oligarchy and tyranny. In the Politicus, as in the Laws, the philosopher deviates from the order of the Republic and gives a preference to democracy over oligarchy.
Plato, then, adopting the popular classification, adds certain ethical considerations, which serve to divide the better forms of each type from the worse.
80 291 D (fjAvapxLa-, 17 vtto tujc 6\Lywit Svvaffreia., rj tov TrXyOovs
21 Mem. iv 6 12 j3a<ri\eta is ^k^vtiijv r<2v avftptlnrtijv *al /caret p6^tovs; rvpcavls is the opposite.
22 It is not easy to see how poverty or wealth would serve to differentiate one kind of democracy from another.
23 This principle also appears in Xenophon, I. c.