Scanned text contains errors.
8 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
supposed order of deviation from the ideal. Thus 'the government of honour,' the description of which is based on the Cretan and Lacedaemonian states, ranks first of the perversions18: next comes oligarchy, the government of wealth,' laden with divers evils",' and below these are democracy and tyranny. No attempt is made to distinguish the better forms of these constitutions from the worse: all are included in the condemnation.
In the Laws, a work written in all probability within the last ten years of Plato's life, when he had realised the hopeless impossibility of his ideal, we have his final thoughts on politics". His classification of ordinary governments is not so clear as in the Republic. In one passage monarchy and democracy are ranked as ' mother forms' above other constitutions15: in another passage the rule of a perfect tyrant is said to be best", and existing governments are considered, according as they are capable of being transformed into this form17. He thus ranks them in the order of tyranny, 'monarchy, democracy and oligarchy. It seems that Plato had really changed his opinion of democracy and now set it above oligarchy, but he is still in irreconcilable hostility to ordinary forms of government. They do not deserve the names of 'constitutions,' they are factions governing without justice in the interest of the rulers19. The state that is to remedy the prevailing defects, if less ideal than the state of the Republic, is not more possible19. It is a government of
M Rep. viii 547—8.
13 Ib. 544 a. It is described in 550 c.
14 Newman, Introduction p. 434, n. 2.
» iii 693 d. 16 iv 709 £. " iv 710 b.
18 iv 715 b. 19 See Jowett, Plato1, v p. xxxvii.