The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 2] CLASSIFICATION OF THE PHILOSOPHERS. 7

tion, in so far as it differs from the popular theory, is based primarily on ethical considerations. The classifica­tions of Plato and Aristotle must be discussed in some detail. The speculations of both writers are intimately connected with attempts to construct ideal states on the Greek model. Both of them observed the conditions that prevailed in the ordinary Greek communities; neither of them conceived of anything beyond the city-state. Even Plato's Republic, however impossible of realisation, does but depict the government of philosophers on the basis of the Lacedaemonian state*. Hence we may often discern real institutions underlying the ideal, and the Utopias of Plato and Aristotle, in so far as they reflect the political theory of the Greeks, have their value in the study of actual constitutions. At the same time the introduction of the ideal state, as the end of political enquiry, tended to divorce the classification of ordinary states from reality. To Plato ' the ideal view of politics probably seemed the only view worth taking. Politics is to him a more concrete sort of Ethics*' and ' the construction of the ideal state is to him more or less an episode in an ethical inquiry9.' The ideal state of the Republic embodies a constitution for Mars or Saturn, or, as Plato himself says, ' it exists nowhere on earth, but a pattern of it is laid up in heaven10'; 'it is suited only for gods or the sons of gods11.' Real constitutions, when compared with this political paradise, can only appear ludicrous perversions of justice, and they are estimated fancifully enough in their

7 Jowett, Plato*, v p. xxxviii.

8 Newman, Introduction p. 486.

8 16. p. 455. w Rep. ix 592 A, u.

11 Laws, v 739 d ; ix 853 o.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

6

7

8
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW