Scanned text contains errors.
6 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.
mentions all three forms and has much to say about the relative merits of democracy and oligarchy*1.
These instances suffice to show that the threefold division of constitutions was generally accepted.
§ 2. Classification of Constitutions by the Philosophers.
The sophistic movement gave a great impetus to the criticism of constitutional forms, and the philosophers also devoted no little interest to the study of politics. The theory of Socrates is preserved for us in the pages of Xenophon, the most faithful exponent of his master's teaching1. Plato has different schemes in the Republic, the Politicus and the Laws*, and Aristotle in three passages discusses the classification of constitutions*. Of later writers Polybius*. Plutarch5 and Dion Chrysostom6 follow Aristotle in the main, with some variation of phraseology. All these writers, while distinguishing constitutions by the number of those to whom sovereign power is entrusted> recognise more than three varieties; and their classifica-
41 The three forms are enumerated in zxiii 66. The orator offers ns a good instance of the commonplace contrast of oligarchy and democracy, for a somewhat frigid passage in which the two forms are compared occurs both in xxii 51—2 and xxiv 163—4.
1 Mem. iv 6 12.
s Rep. v 449 a ; Pol. 291 ff.; Laws, 710 E.
3 The scheme in the Rhetoric (i 8 1365) has a great resemblance to the scheme in Xenophon, while it differs considerably from that in the Politics (iii chs. 6—9), wherein Aristotle adopts in the main the classification of Plato in the Politicus. There is a third scheme in the Ethict (viii 12 1160) resembling the classification of the Politict with some slight variations in the definitions.
4 vi cos. 3—10. s De unitu dam. 3. « iii 46—9.