The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

§ 1] POPULAR CLASSIFICATION. 5

In these respects he anticipates Aristotle, and it is clear that the philosopher to a great extent follows the historian both in his phraseology and in his general descriptions. To Thucydides the Peloponnesian war was a conflict of political principles, a duel between oligarchy and democracy": it was even more particularly a trial of strength between the free and popular constitution of Athens and the rigid, military aristocracy of Sparta. Hence he is haunted by the antithesis afforded by these two states; and it is scarcely an exaggeration to say that there are few speeches in which traces of this antithesis cannot be found, while it is emphasized or implied on occasions when the introduction of the contrast is in­appropriate to the speaker and irrelevant".

To continue the examination of the popular classifica­tion : Thrasymachus in Plato's Republic refers to the three ordinary constitutions under the names of tyranny, aris­tocracy and democracy18. Isocrates enumerates them and further differentiates them by their ethical qualities—a distinction to which I refer below". Aeschines introduces the comparison in order to draw conclusions in favour of the fairness and good order of democracy". Demosthenes

" Cf. especially iii 82 1.

17 The contrast of the character of the two states is natural and avowed in the speech of the Corinthians (i 68—71) and in that of Archi-damus (i 80—86). In the praise of Athens by Pericles Sparta serves as a foil to her great rival (ii 35 ft., see especially chapters 37, 39, 40). The contrast does not seem so relevant in the month of Cleon (iii 37—40), bat it is obviously implied though not avowed; for Cleon is made to repeat the description of the Spartans given by the Corinthians and Archidamus. Lastly, the comparison is made by Nicias (vi 11).

18 i 338 d.

M iii 132—3. [Lys.] vi 30 enumerates Srjpos, 6\i-yapxla. and rtfpwros.

» In Timarch. 4.

Pages
About | Contents | Index

4

5

6
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW