The Ancient Library
 

Scanned text contains errors.

4 CLASSIFICATION OF CONSTITUTIONS. [CH. I.

particular events the searching analysis of motive, the masterly application of general principles, which make Thucydides an author for all time12. In the speeches, moreover, there is a tragic irony, a foreknowledge of the catastrophe which reminds us again of the analogy. The splendid panegyric of Athens put into the mouth of Peri­cles is followed without a break by the narrative of the plague—the first step in the downfall of Athens. The assertion of the empire of force at Melos and the warnings of the Melian speakers prepare the way for that master­piece of tragic narrative, the story of the disaster in Sicily. Hence though the speeches are often not inconsistent with the character of the speaker and are appropriate enough to.the circumstances of the occasion", they may be re­garded rather as containing the reflections of Thucydides himself than as the actual words or thoughts of the orator to whom they are attributed. Thucydides is nowhere concerned with the comparison of the three constitutions, but he shows that he has carried the analysis of constitu­tional forms much further than his predecessors. His classification is more accurate, varieties of the main types are distinguished", and the characteristics of the different governments are drawn in more detail and with greater precision18.

18 Thucydides rarely inserts his own comment on events. The most noteworthy instance is the reflection on the <rr<ur» at Corcyra (iii 82—3).

13 Thucydides himself says (i 22) (it S' &» iStncovv i/uH iko.cttm rept tut del irap&rner rd Stotrra. it4\i<rr eltcfiv, ixop£nf oti (yyifrraTa. rfft (v/trAmit •yvwMT row dXij0ws \ex0frrw, otrrwj ctynp-eu.

14 In i 13 TvpantSet and Tarpucal 0<urt\euu are distinguished. In iii 62 6\tya.pxta- laktoiun and Swcurreia are distinguished.

>' Cf. the descriptions of the Athenian democracy (ii 38) and of the moderate democracy at Syracuse (vi 39).

Pages
About | Contents | Index

3

4

5
page  
Search this site
Google


isidore-of-seville.com
WWW