This book has been edited to fit the internet.


Chapter 7

COMBUSTIBLE, VULNERABLE, & EXPENDABLE


Time-Line, Events, & Comments

What makes this book unique is the use of a time-line for all events, all listed in chronological, time-line order. The events in Chapters two through nine are listed in the order in which the author believes they occurred. Entries listed simply as "EVENT" are also placed in a chronological, time-line order and are closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. Comments by the author associated with events are often listed also. Entries are displayed as follows:

0708 A time-specific event, in the order in which the author believes they actually occurred.
EVENT A specific event, closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event.
A/C Author's Comment. A personal explanation of events by the author.

Wednesday, October 25, 1944

EVENT The Japanese heavy cruisers continue to concentrate their fire on CVE GAMBIER BAY. She is now far behind the other escort carriers and is easy prey for the Japanese ships as she is just barely making way. The next shell strikes the pilot house, killing all men in it and as a result the ship loses all steerageway. The same salvo enters the port engine room and pierces No. 3 boiler and the steam generating tubes, leaving the escort carrier with no propulsion capability.
0845 Destroyer HEERMANN is hit by 8-inch gunfire. Four men on the bridge are killed including the helmsman.
EVENT Destroyer Escort ROBERTS passes DD HOEL, which is dead in the water. Severely damaged, burning, and listing to port with her fantail awash, her crew can be seen abandoning ship.
A/C Lieutenant Commander Copeland of ROBERTS knew it was his duty to come to the aid of HOEL's men. Because of the dire predicament the escort carriers were in, and the number of lives involved, should a CVE be sunk, he decided not to aide HOEL but continue on and further engage the Japanese warships.
EVENT Destroyer JOHNSTON engages BB KONGO at 7,000 yards and scores about 15 hits. Battleship KONGO returns fire and misses.
A/C Throughout the battle the Japanese heavy ships were forced to fire on the small American destroyers and destroyer escorts through smoke and rain, often unable to tell friend from foe. In this case, JOHNSTON is three and one-half miles from KONGO, is under limited propulsion, and still manages to engage KONGO without being hit in return.
EVENT Aircraft from Taffy II arrive and focus on CA SUZUYA. She is fatally crippled after several hits.
A/C SUZUYA was the second heavy cruiser to be hit during the Battle Off Samar. She never recovered from this damage and became a choice target of the American aircraft throughout the engagement.
EVENT Heavy cruiser CHIKUMA falls prey and is hit by aircraft from CVE GAMBIER BAY's Composite Squadron VC-10.
EVENT Destroyers HAYASHIMO and HAMANAMI of Destroyer Squadron 2 are damaged by aircraft.
A/C The aircraft of Taffy II were now in the area en mass, effectively attacking the ships of Centre Force. This was the first coordinated large-scale effective strike of the day, responsible for finishing off two heavy cruisers and damaging several other ships.
0848 Admiral Halsey, urged on by VADM Kinkaid's pleas for help, cancels his previous order to Task Group 38.1. He orders VADM McCain to steam southwest at maximum speed and to launch an attack against Centre Force. Task Group 38.1 is presently refueling, about 400 miles distant to the southeast.
0850 Escort Carrier GAMBIER BAY, dead in the water, is hit by 8-inch shells nearly every minute. With fires and flooding increasing by the minute, Captain Vieweg realizes his ship is lost. Reluctantly he orders all hands to abandon ship. Although CVE GAMBIER BAY is being systematically destroyed by the Japanese warships with no hope of survival, the captain refuses to strike her colors.
A/C GAMBIER BAY's crew would tragically spend well over two days in the water before being rescued.
EVENT Escort Carrier FANSHAW BAY is hit by a 6-inch shell from TONE.
EVENT Destroyer Escort ROBERTS sights 14-inch battleship shell splashes closing her from astern. Contemplating the fall of the next shell, DE ROBERTS rings up "ALL BACK FULL" to take off speed. The ship quickly slows and the next shell lands an equal distance ahead of her.
A/C The battleships' fire control solution on ROBERTS was clearly correct.
EVENT Destroyer Escort DENNIS is hit by an 8-inch armor-piercing shell. It punches a clean hole through her, port to starboard, just above the water line. The damage control party in the CPO Quarters is killed and the forward ammunition magazine is flooded.
EVENT Vice Admiral Kinkaid instructs RADM Oldendorf, Commander of the Bombardment and Support Group, to move several of his ships to the southern and eastern approaches to Leyte Gulf in lieu of supporting the Taffies.
EVENT Rear Admiral Oldendorf orders his Battle Line commander to take the battleships TENNESSEE, CALIFORNIA and PENNSYLVANIA, heavy cruisers' LOUISVILLE, PORTLAND, MINNEAPOLIS, NASHVILLE, HMAS SHROPSHIRE, and two destroyer squadrons 25 miles eastward where they would be in a position to sortie in support of the Taffies.
A/C The choice of battleships is interesting. TENNESSEE and CALIFORNIA fought well during the battle of Surigao Strait with their new MK-8 gunnery fire control radars. WEST VIRGINIA, which fired the most AP rounds, was not ordered to sortie to support the Taffies, probably because her supply of AP ammunition was nearly exhausted. PENNSYLVANIA on the other hand, did not fire her main batteries during the Battle of Surigao Strait due to the poor performance of her old MK-3 gunnery fire control radar. PENNSYLVANIA was therefore probably the most well off, ammunition-wise.
0851 Destroyer Escort ROBERTS rings up "ALL AHEAD FLANK." Before she can gain adequate speed she is hit by three 8-inch armor-piercing shells from the heavy cruisers.
A/C Closed in on three sides by Japanese ships, ROBERTS was a sitting-duck once she lost steerageway.
EVENT Aboard DE ROBERTS, one 8-inch shell strikes below the waterline and causes flooding, one hits the IC room knocking out communications and electrical power, and the last ruptures the main steam line in the forward engine room. Badly mauled, DE ROBERTS takes on water, unable to obtain her maximum speed, which had been reduced to seventeen knots. She now becomes the focal point of all Japanese gunfire.
0853 Thirty US carrier planes attack heavy cruisers' CHIKUMA, TONE, HAGURO, and CHOKAI.
A/C American aircraft continued to arrive in greater numbers from Taffies I and II. This airpower contributed significantly to the outcome of the battle, slowing the Japanese pursuit of the escort carriers and aiding in their escape.
0855 USS HOEL (DD 533) rolls over on her port side and sinks stern first. She is the first ship of Taffy III to be sunk by Centre Force.
A/C HOEL lost 253 destroyermen when she sunk, fifteen more perished on the rafts and flotation nets the next day.
EVENT Escort Carrier FANSHAW BAY is hit by a 6-inch shell on the forward end of her flight deck.
0858 Escort Carrier FANSHAW BAY is hit again by another 6-inch shell.
0900 Destroyer Escort DENNIS is hit by three more 8-inch shells from CA TONE. One shell destroys her 40mm director and kills four men. The second creates a small hole in her port side aft and cuts electrical cables. The last shell glances off the forward 5-inch mount shaking up all men inside of it.
0900 The heavy cruisers resume pouring their fire at CVE KITKUN BAY and drop a salvo 200 yards astern of the ship. The cruisers are now about 12,000 yards away, approaching from the port beam. Having expended most of her 5-inch shells during the mornings ordeal, the captain orders the 5-inch mount to cease fire.
A/C The captain gave the order to cease fire because he wanted to reserve the remaining 5-inch shells to help repel an expected Japanese destroyer attack.
EVENT Destroyer Escort ROBERTS, under increasingly intense gunfire, is hit by three 14-inch shells from BB KONGO ripping a 30-40 foot hole in her port side near the waterline. The impact of the shells is so great that all hands are knocked down to the deck. Fires start and her engineroom is knocked out. Still under fire and flooding uncontrollably, she slows to a dead stop.
EVENT At that moment, a torpedo track is sighted running straight toward DE ROBERTS. Word is passed to standby for torpedo impact. The torpedo passes harmlessly under her keel.
EVENT The five remaining escort carriers continue southward firing their single 5-inch guns as they run. Escort carrier FANSHAW BAY scores five hits with her 5-inch gun on CA CHIKUMA, one brings smoke from her superstructure. Meanwhile, CVE WHITE PLAINS puts six shells into CA CHOKAI, causing damage.
EVENT Admiral Halsey with Third Fleet, presently far to the north, east of Luzon, receives a plain-English message from VADM Kinkaid: "ENEMY FORCE ATTACKED OUR CVE'S COMPOSED OF 4 BB'S 8 CRUISERS AND OTHER SHIPS. REQUEST (VADM) LEE PROCEED TOP SPEED COVER LEYTE. REQUEST IMMEDIATE STRIKE BY FAST CARRIERS.
A/C This was one of many urgent messages VADM Kinkaid sent to ADM Halsey requesting immediate assistance. Admiral Halsey became annoyed by the constant stream of messages requesting assistance and wondered why VADM Kinkaid left his northern flank exposed. He felt Third Fleet was not responsible for protecting Seventh Fleet; his mission was to strike with his fleet against all contingencies.
0901 The heavy cruisers straddle CVE KITKUN BAY with 8-inch shells on both sides of the ship. Seconds later another lands 20 yards astern. Expecting the next salvo to cause serious damage, the captain swings the ship between 200 T and 270 T in an effort to forestall the apparently inevitable. By the grace of God, the Japanese cease their fire on CVE KITKUN BAY.
A/C For a brief moment, it appeared KITKUN BAY would meet the same fate as GAMBIER BAY.
0902 More planes of Taffy II's second wave of aircraft arrive on the scene.
EVENT Heavy cruiser CHIKUMA is struck by two torpedoes from aircraft of Taffy II. She turns hard to port with a large fire on her fantail.
A/C This particular heavy cruiser took an extraordinary amount of punishment before sinking.
EVENT Destroyer Escort DENNIS turns into DE BUTLER's smoke screen to make repairs, both of her 5-inch guns out of action.
0905 Heavy cruiser CHOKAI is put out of action by aircraft from CVE KITKUN BAY. The pilots take her by surprise and land two very-near misses, one direct hit astern, three direct hits on the bow and five more amidships. She drifts to a halt severely damaged and ablaze.
EVENT Heavy cruisers TONE and HAGURO close to 10,000 yards and continue to fire on the escort carriers, scoring some hits.
EVENT In single column, Destroyer Squadron 10, led by CL YAHAGI and destroyers URAKAZE, ISOKAZE, YUKIKAZE, and NOWAKI position to attack the escort carriers with torpedoes at very long range. Light cruiser YAHAGI fires her torpedoes at 15,000 yards.
0905 Destroyer HEERMANN positions to the rear of Taffy III and lays more smoke behind the fleeing carriers.
EVENT Destroyer Squadron 10 approaches the escort carriers from the starboard flank. Destroyer JOHNSTON, acting on her own, closes range and engages the entire destroyer squadron with gunfire and scores twelve 5-inch gun hits on the flagship, light cruiser YAHAGI. Her torpedoes away, CL YAHAGI turns away to starboard and the destroyers of Squadron 10 soon appear to follow.
A/C YAHAGI was following Japanese naval tactics doctrine. It was standard procedures to turn away from a target after launching torpedoes; allowing the next ship in line to fire its torpedoes, and so on. However, JOHNSTON's stubborn boldness paid off, forcing the Japanese ships to fire their torpedoes at the escort carriers too soon.
EVENT The destroyers' URAKAZE, ISOKAZE, YUKIKAZE, and NOWAKI hit DD JOHNSTON with gunfire and retire.
EVENT Light cruiser YAHAGI, still opening the distance, fires more torpedoes at the fleeing escort carriers, all miss.
EVENT Heavy cruisers TONE and HAGURO, the most fit of the remaining Japanese cruisers, concentrate their gunfire on DD JOHNSTON.
0907 With a Japanese cruiser still shooting at her about one mile off her beam, USS GAMBIER BAY (CVE 73) capsizes to port and sinks into the Philippine Trench, the only US carrier sunk by naval gunfire in World War II.
A/C Captain Vieweg, Commanding Officer of GAMBIER BAY, was in the water near his ship as she was sinking. He noted a Japanese cruiser about 2,000 yards distant was still shooting at GAMBIER BAY, and still missing.
EVENT Heavy cruisers TONE and HAGURO are the nearest threat to the remaining escort carriers. With most of the screening ships sinking, sunk, or damaged, CA TONE and CA HAGURO are able to use their superior speed to close the range on the escort carriers unopposed. Their 8-inch salvos increase in accuracy.
EVENT Escort Carrier KITKUN BAY is frequently damaged by shrapnel from near-misses.
EVENT Escort Carrier WHITE PLAINS is hit by 6-inch shells from CL NOSHIRO, flagship of Destroyer Squadron 2. Near-missed shake the ship.
EVENT Escort Carrier FANSHAW BAY is hit by four 8-inch shells, including two very near misses. One hit holes her below the waterline and one severely damages her flight deck. Three of her crew are killed and 20 are wounded.
EVENT Escort Carrier KALININ BAY is hit by eleven 8-inch cruiser shells and one 14-inch battleship shell. Her main steering control is knocked out and she has to be steered by hand.
EVENT One shell hits KALININ BAY's forward elevator and destroys the platform. Several armor-piercing shells pass through her hull without exploding.
A/C With the three most aggressive American ships out of the picture (JOHNSTON, HOEL, & ROBERTS), and the range decreasing by the minute, the Japanese are able to pour on very effective gunfire. The escort carriers are now once again on the verge of being wiped out.
EVENT Destroyer HEERMANN fires on a "MAYA" Class cruiser, possibly CA TONE, and rejoins the escort carriers to lay more smoke.
0910 Under pressure from the destroyers and heavy cruisers, RADM Sprague orders the destroyer escorts to, once again, attack.
EVENT Listing eleven degrees and settling by the stern, the men of DE ROBERTS are ordered to abandon ship.
A/C Captain Copeland has surveyed ROBERTS and found that both 5-inch guns were inoperable, communications were lost, and the engines had been knocked out. From the stack aft, the area reaching to the stern of the ship was hopelessly battered. Dead and wounded men littered her deck.

Back to Chapter 6 - Her Fate is Sealed

Forward to Chapter 8 - Resolution, Sacrifice, & Success

Return to Book Index Page

Return to Menu Page


Honor the Missing in Action and Killed in Action of Taffy III

We do remember.  We won't forget.


Robert Jon Cox [email protected]
last revised August 21 1996
Copyright Robert Jon Cox 1996 all rights reserved
Void where prohibited.