
This book has been edited to fit the internet.
Chapter 6
HER FATE IS SEALED
Time-Line, Events, & Comments
What makes this book unique is the use of a time-line for all events, all listed in chronological, time-line order. The events in Chapters two through nine are listed in the order in which the author believes they occurred. Entries listed simply as "EVENT" are also placed in a chronological, time-line order and are closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. Comments by the author associated with events are often listed also. Entries are displayed as follows:
| 0708 | A time-specific event, in the order in which the author believes they actually occurred. |
| EVENT | A specific event, closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. |
| A/C | Author's Comment. A personal explanation of events by the author. |
Wednesday, October 25, 1944
| 0800 | The six escort carriers of Taffy III are ordered to change course from south to southwest. They are steaming in two uneven rows abreast, nearly a circular formation. They are making their top speed of just over 17.5 knots. |
| A/C | This single maneuver eventually leads to the sinking of GAMBIER BAY. Had they not changed course, another, or perhaps several other escort carriers possibly would have been sunk. |
| 0800 | Fifteen-thousand yards now separate the fleeing escort carriers from the pursuing Japanese heavy cruisers. The battleships, coming up the center, are not far behind. All ships continue to fire on the escort carriers of Taffy III. |
| EVENT | Escort Carrier WHITE PLAINS leads the task unit, in the center of the forward line, just ahead of the others. She is closely followed by CVE's KITKUN BAY and flagship CVE FANSHAW BAY. Trailing on the starboard flank is CVE ST LO; all are masked by the dense smoke screen put up by themselves and the screening ships. |
| EVENT | The new course taken by Taffy III places escort carriers GAMBIER BAY and KALININ BAY on the exposed port flank, nearest to the Japanese cruiser line. Although they too are making smoke, the wind blows their smoke screen southward, exposing them both to the pursuing ships gunfire. The two unfortunate escort carriers now become the focal point of the Japanese heavy caliber gunfire. |
| EVENT | With the range between the escort carriers and cruisers closing drastically, RADM Sprague orders the escort carriers to "...open fire with the pea-shooters when the range is clear...", referring to the escort carriers single 5-inch gun. Shortly after observing the defensive gunfire, one old Chief Petty Officer on CVE ST LO was heard to say, "They ought to fire that thing underwater, we could use a little jet propulsion right now!" |
| A/C | In just over one hour, the heavy cruisers have closed the range on the escort carriers by nearly 20,000 yards (ten miles) from their initial contact point. Now, at a range of seven and one-half miles, 15,000 yards, they were well within their main batteries effective range to eliminate the entire group with 8-inch gunfire. |
| 0803 | Destroyer HEERMANN completes her gunnery dual with the BB HARUNA and turns southward to catch up with the escort carriers. Still well within range of the battleships big guns, she is forced to chase salvos during her retreat. |
| 0805 | Escort Carrier KALININ BAY, the tail-end ship, is hit by an 8-inch heavy cruiser shell. |
| 0809 | Destroyer Escort DENNIS joins destroyers' HEERMANN, JOHNSTON and DE ROBERTS, about 7 to 10 thousands behind, as they head back toward the escort carriers. The latter two are seriously damaged and have limited propulsion. |
| A/C | JOHNSTON and ROBERTS, both heavily damaged, would never catch up with the escort carriers. Commander Evans and LCDR Copeland fought their ships to the last. |
| 0810 | The Japanese CA CHIKUMA closes to within five miles, of the escort carriers, finds the range of CVE GAMBIER BAY, and sets her aft flight deck ablaze with 8-inch shell fire. |
| EVENT | Battleships' HARUNA and KONGO sight the escort carriers of RADM Stump's Task Unit 77.4.2 (Taffy II) to the southeast and assume they are six more Third Fleet INDEPENDENCE Class carriers. |
| A/C | Taffy II was steaming into the wind on a northeasterly course, conducting flight operations. Although it drew them much closer to Centre Force and the immediate battle area, it was a necessity. The wind was coming from the northeast. In order to launch their heavily laden aircraft, the wind had to be over the decks of the escort carriers. |
| A/C | Rear Admiral Stump had the luxury of being just out of harms way for the entire battle. He was therefore able to provide significant assistance to his sister Taffy. Matching VADM Kinkaid's order early that morning, he had directed his carrier CO's to be ready to load anti-shipping ordnance on short notice. Due to this factor, Taffy II was able to quickly provide a balanced attack force of fighters and torpedo bombers. The men on the escort carriers of Taffy II worked strenuously, launching and rearming countless planes, many were orphans from the escort carriers of Taffy III. |
| A/C | In their attack, the pilots of Taffy II were directed not to concentrate on single vessels, but to damage as many enemy ships as possible. |
| EVENT | Upon completion of air operations, RADM Stump, embarked in flagship CVE NATOMA BAY, orders the escort carriers of Taffy II turned away from the Japanese. |
| EVENT | Taffy II receives word that two Japanese battleships are heading their way at an estimated 27 knots. As the escort carriers of Taffy II head away from the battle area, the three destroyers of Taffy II, HAGGARD, HAILEY and FRANKS, take up a defensive position in the rear of their task unit. The destroyers are ordered to "...PREPARED FOR TORPEDO ATTACK AGAINST UNITS OF THE JAPANESE FLEET...." |
| A/C | Taffy II's destroyers never did have to make a torpedo attack. Shortly thereafter, the Japanese battleships reversed course and head north with the remainder of Centre Force to regroup. |
| EVENT | Taffy II's destroyer escorts SUESENS, ABERCROMBIE, OBERRENDER, WILSON, and WANN are directed to prepare their torpedoes and standby for possible action against the Japanese fleet. |
| EVENT | At long range, battleships' KONGO and HARUNA fire on the destroyers of Taffy II. Fourteen-inch shell splashes rise near the destroyers' HAGGARD, HAILEY and FRANKS, which are reported by the Japanese as BALTIMORE class heavy cruisers. |
| A/C | The further mis-classification of ship types by the Japanese had an ever increasing negative affect on their decision not to pursue the American carriers. |
| EVENT | Escort Carrier GAMBIER BAY, unable to hide behind the smoke screen created by herself, the other carriers, and her screen, continues to take the majority of the punishment. The Japanese pour on effective fire and she is hit nearly every other minute. |
| A/C | The heavy cruisers still resorted to use armor-piercing shells. The majority of the shells passed through GAMBIER BAY's thin-skinned hull without exploding, some even bounced across her flight deck. |
| A/C | GAMBIER BAY's predicament was looking grim. The number of holes in her, punched cleanly through by the armor- piercing shells, were too numerous to count. |
| EVENT | Heavy cruisers' CHIKUMA, TONE, HAGURO, and CHOKAI concentrate their fire on CVE GAMBIER BAY from her port side. On the starboard side, CL NOSHIRO and at least one destroyer join in, closing the range to well under five miles. |
| A/C | Quoting CVE KITKUN BAY's Ship's History, "...the leading enemy cruisers were concentrating their fire on our nearest ship the GAMBIER BAY, and all hands on our ship offered a prayer in their hearts for the well being of our many friends on this companion of over 70,000 miles of war time cruising, successful cooperation, and friendly rivalry...." |
| EVENT | The men of CVE GAMBIER BAY tried desperately to fight the fires as they erupted, but could not keep up with the damage which was being inflicted upon their ship. Many soon realized they would not be afloat much longer. |
| 0814 | Destroyer escort RAYMOND, on the port side of the escort carrier formation, fires on CA CHIKUMA with her two 5-inch guns. |
| 0820 | A single 8-inch shell from CA CHIKUMA explodes in the water near CVE GAMBIER BAY and holes the forward engine room plates near No. 1 boiler which results in uncontrollable flooding. Nineteen-thousand gallons of water per minute rushes in. This single shell seals her fate. |
| EVENT | Escort Carrier GAMBIER BAY's boilers are secured to prevent an explosion as water rises waist-deep in her forward engine room. Electrical power in the forward part of the ship is lost and communications fail in the boiler room. Two portable electric bilge pumps are placed in the engine room to combat the flooding. |
| EVENT | The in-rushing water is beyond the capacity of the drain pumps and cannot be displaced fast enough. Soon the bulkhead between the engine room and the forward machine shop fails. |
| EVENT | With her boilers secured and taking on thousands of tons of water, CVE GAMBIER BAY lists to port and her speed is reduced to 11 knots. She falls out of formation. The remaining escort carriers of Taffy III continue southward, leaving CVE GAMBIER BAY to her fate. |
| 0822 | Admiral Halsey receives a plain-English message from Admiral Kinkaid:"FAST BATTLESHIPS ARE URGENTLY NEEDED IMMEDIATELY AT LEYTE GULF." |
| 0825 | With its single 5-inch gun, CVE KALININ BAY hits CA CHIKUMA, quickly followed by another which brings fire and smoke from the cruisers' turret. |
| 0826 | Rear Admiral Sprague orders destroyer escorts DENNIS and BUTLER to interpose between the CVE's and the heavy cruisers on the port quarter. Destroyer escort RAYMOND, already on the port side, responds and joins with other two. |
| EVENT | Word is passed to the escort carriers, "...screen reports all torpedoes expended...." |
| A/C | There was one ship left with torpedoes, DE BUTLER still had her full complement of three. |
| 0828 | Destroyer escort RAYMOND opens fire on heavy cruisers CHIKUMA and TONE, expending 414 rounds of ammunition during the entire days action. Both cruisers return fire and miss. |
| 0828 | An 8-inch salvo lands 1,000 yards astern of CVE KITKUN BAY. Captain Whitney, like the other escort carrier CO's, resorts to ziz-zagging to upset the enemy range calculations. The salvos, unrelenting, keep coming closer.... |
| 0830 | Destroyer HOEL, far north of the escort carriers, maintains limited propulsion, albeit on one engine, for over one and a half hours. Finally, unable to maneuver as the cruiser range closes, her starboard engine is put out of action by an 8-inch shell. |
| 0830 | A salvo lands 100 yards off the port beam of CVE KITKUN BAY. |
| EVENT | Damaged beyond repair from her duel with battleships and heavy cruisers, DD HOEL drifts to a dead stop. |
| 0830 | Heavy cruiser CHIKUMA closes to within 6,000 yards and concentrates her 8-inch gun fire on CVE GAMBIER BAY. In an attempt to draw fire away from CVE GAMBIER BAY, CDR Evans of DD JOHNSTON orders, "...commence firing on the cruiser, Hagen. Draw her fire away from the GAMBIER BAY...." She makes at least five hits with little effect, largely being ignored by the cruiser. |
| 0831 | Straddled effectively by the cruisers, a salvo hits the water 700 yards astern of CVE KITKUN BAY. |
| 0832 | A salvo hits 500 yards from the starboard beam of CVE KITKUN BAY. |
| 0833 | Sixteen Avenger torpedo-bombers and 8 fighter aircraft are launched from the escort carriers of Taffy II. |
| 0835 | Down by the stern, "Prepare to abandon ship" is announced on DD HOEL. |
| 0835 | Destroyer HEERMANN, coming to the aid of DD JOHNSTON, passes through the CVE formation at flank bell and nearly collides with CVE FANSHAW BAY, passing closely astern of her. Her deck log reads, "0835 - Back emergency full to avoid collision with FANSHAW BAY, which crossed our bow from port to starboard." |
| A/C | The dense smoke screen was hampering the American effort as well. |
| 0838 | Rear Admiral Sprague sends a message in the clear to Rear Admiral Tommy Sprague, Commander Task Group 77.4:"UNDER ATTACK...ENEMY COMPOSED OF FOUR BATTLESHIPS, 8 CA MANY DESTROYERS." |
| 0840 | Destroyer HEERMANN arrives on the port side of the CVE formation only to bear down now on DD JOHNSTON which is having difficulty steering. HEERMANN has to place her engines in all-back emergency, missing JOHNSTON by a mere three inches. |
| 0841 | Escort carrier GAMBIER BAY is burning amidships and lists 20 degrees to port. She is engaged by heavy cruisers CHIKUMA, HAGURO, and CHOKAI, CL NOSHIRO, and one destroyer. |
| 0841 | Destroyer HEERMANN engages CA CHIKUMA with gun fire from about 12,000 yards. With her guns locked on CVE GAMBIER BAY, the heavy cruiser turns in a tight circle and shifts part of her fire to DD HEERMANN. |
| A/C | Caught in the midsts of several Japanese warships, DD HEERMANN was now pressing her luck. |
| EVENT | Two Japanese heavy cruisers are now rapidly closing on the carrier formation. |
| EVENT | Unable to rely upon his destroyers for further attacks, RADM Sprague orders the destroyer escorts to engage the cruiser line. Destroyer escorts ROBERTS and RAYMOND on the port side of the escort carriers, immediately engage the cruiser line. On the starboard quarter, destroyer escorts DENNIS and BUTLER cross the escort carrier formation, lay smoke, and join the attack on the lead cruiser. |
| EVENT | Destroyer Escort ROBERTS' effective 5-inch gun fire, about 300 rounds from two turrets, knocks out CHIKUMA's #3 8-inch turret, destroying her bridge and starting fires aft. |
| A/C | During its free-for-all with CHIKUMA, the two gun mounts on ROBERTS were literally firing everything they had without consideration for type of ammunition. As a result, CHIKUMA was hit with armor-piercing, common antiaircraft, proximity fuse, star shells, and plugged target projectiles. |
| EVENT | Destroyer Escort RAYMOND closes to within 5,900 yards of the cruiser line, guns firing. |
| EVENT | Destroyer Escort BUTLER, running abeam of CA CHIKUMA, attempts to launch her torpedoes but cannot obtain a suitable firing position. BUTLER hits CHIKUMA with 5-inch gun fire. |
| EVENT | Destroyer Escort DENNIS' #2 5-inch gun mount becomes inoperative due to a broken breach. She remains in action with her remaining gun. |
Back to Chapter 5 - Small Boys Screening Action
Forward to Chapter 7 - Combustible, Vulnerable, and Expendable
Honor the Missing in Action and Killed in Action of Taffy III
We do remember. We won't forget.