This book has been edited to fit the internet.


Chapter 8

RESOLUTION, SACRIFICE, & SUCCESS


Time-Line, Events, & Comments

What makes this book unique is the use of a time-line for all events, all listed in chronological, time-line order. The events in Chapters two through nine are listed in the order in which the author believes they occurred. Entries listed simply as "EVENT" are also placed in a chronological, time-line order and are closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. Comments by the author associated with events are often listed also. Entries are displayed as follows:

0708 A time-specific event, in the order in which the author believes they actually occurred.
EVENT A specific event, closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event.
A/C Author's Comment. A personal explanation of events by the author.

Wednesday, October 25, 1944

0911 Vice Admiral Kurita aboard BB YAMATO, sends an immediate message to all ships ordering:

    "CEASE ACTION, COME NORTH WITH ME, 20 KNOTS."

The remaining ships of Centre Force begin to break off their attack against the remaining units of Taffy III and head northward to regroup.

A/C Vice Admiral Kurita had clearly had enough and thought now was the time to regroup. His tactical picture of the battle from his vantage point far to the north was foggy at best. The ships of Centre Force were scattered over a wide area of ocean with no cohesiveness in their attack. Several of his heavy cruisers had by now succumb to the increasingly heavy air attacks by taffy aircraft. He also reasoned that since it was well over two hours since he ordered "general attack", the "heavy" carriers had all but gotten away and were well ahead of his pursuing lead units.
A/C The constant assault by carrier borne aircraft was taking its toll on VADM Kurita's remaining ships and weighed heavily in his decision to regroup. The American pilots from all three Taffies harassed Centre Force relentlessly with and without torpedoes, bombs, or ammunition for their guns. These efforts alone were the greatest significant factor contributing to Centre Force's calculated retreat. Also, the sighting of Taffy II to the southeast led him to believe additional heavy U.S. carrier forces were nearby and would soon be adding their weight to the air attacks. He saw his only logical defense was to pull his remaining forces together to optimize their combined air defense and to possibly organize another attack as an effective, cohesive unit.
A/C Vice Admiral Kurita was physically exhausted by this point. The entire SHO operation had been a great drain on his personal health. The need to stay alert only maximized as they approached nearer to Leyte Gulf, resulting in little or no sleep.
A/C Also of significance was the actual damage inflicted upon Centre Force since departing Brunei Bay. Originally consisting of thirty-two warships, the entire remaining force now comprised of about sixteen ships. Two days earlier he literally had to swim for his life after his flagship CA ATAGO was sunk beneath him and one other heavy cruiser was sunk. The crippling of another heavy cruiser in Palawan Passage and the need to dispatch two destroyers for escort duty significantly weakened his force. Later the next day during the Battle of the Sibuyan Sea his forces came under heavy air attack by Halsey's Third Fleet task groups which cumulated in the loss of super-battleship MUSASHI. Add to that one more damaged heavy cruiser, including another destroyer for escort duties. The unrelenting U.S. carrier aircraft attacks received by his forces today only lessened his resolve. Unable to get past the heavy American air attacks, the entire SHO-GO plan seemed to be falling apart before his eyes and was now appeared to be failing.
0915 Destroyers URAKAZE, ISOKAZE, YUKIKAZE, and NOWAKI of Destroyer Squadron 10 fire torpedoes at the escort carriers at very long range and miss.
EVENT Shortly after their torpedo attack, the destroyers close range and concentrate on DD JOHNSTON, knocking out her remaining engine and fireroom with effective, nearly point-blank 5-inch gunfire. All power and communications are lost on DD JOHNSTON, ending the destroyers long morning of unrelenting, sustained action.
A/C The torpedo attack by the destroyers of DESRON 10 appeared to be performed half-heatedly. All destroyers fired at an extremely long range without results. Near the end of one torpedo run, as it approached CVE KALININ BAY, the weapon was seen porposing near the surface. An alert pilot returning to CVE ST LO exploded the weapon with gunfire as it neared the surface, about 100 yards astern of the escort carrier. Several other of the torpedoes were seen as they sped harmlessly past the fleeing escort carriers.
A/C The combination of JOHNSTON's stubbornness in challenging the destroyers and VADM Kurita's recall order saved the escort carriers from further losses.
0918 Destroyer escort BUTLER expends all of it's 5-inch ammunition; she is ordered to the head of the escort carrier formation to lay more smoke.
A/C This clearly indicates the intense gunfire action the destroyer escorts' were engaged in throughout the morning. With only two 5-inch guns, BUTLER fired nearly 300 rounds from each at ranges of 5 to 10 miles. One note, although she tried, BUTLER was the only destroyer escort remaining in the screen not to fire her 3 torpedoes.
EVENT As the men of DE ROBERTS carry out abandon ship procedures, a Japanese destroyer continues to throw shells at the helpless vessel.
A/C The ship took four 5-inch hits while abandoning ship, killing six or eight men.
0921 Admiral Halsey receives another plain-English message from RADM Sprague addressed to everyone...Kinkaid, Nimitz, and Tommy Sprague.

    "STILL UNDER ATTACK AT 0830".

0924 Battleship YAMATO, well to the north of the escort carriers and out of contact with the forward ships of Centre Force, reverses course and heads north to regroup.
0925 Unknown to VADM Kurita, heavy cruisers TONE and HAGURO have approached to within 10,000 yards of the remaining, badly damaged escort carriers of Taffy III; nearly point-blank range for their 203mm, 8-inch guns. Following VADM Kurita's orders, they swing hard to port, breaking off their attack and steer northward to regroup with the remaining ships of Centre Force.
EVENT On board flagship CVE FANSHAW BAY, a signalman upon seeing heavy cruisers TONE and HAGURO break off action and turn away, yells, "Goddamit boys, they're getting away!" Their retreat signaled the end of the major surface action of the Battle Off Samar.
A/C The only remaining ships available to screen the escort carriers was DD HEERMANN, and destroyer escorts' BUTLER, DENNIS, and RAYMOND. As stated earlier, only BUTLER had torpedoes remaining, and most if not all of the screen ships suffered from battle damage and were perilously low in 5-inch gun ammunition. Taffy III's remaining screening ships were in no condition to repulse another determined attack. The two remaining Japanese heavy cruisers TONE and HAGURO were in an excellent position to finish off the remaining escort carriers if they chose to press it home.
0927 With his entire fleet engaged with VADM Ozawa to the north, ADM Halsey sends a message to VADM Kinkaid informing him that help is on the way:

    "AM NOW ENGAGING ENEMY CARRIER FORCE. TG 38.1 WITH 5 CARRIERS AND 4 CA'S (cruisers) HAS BEEN ORDERED TO ASSIST YOU IMMEDIATELY."

Belatedly, he also let Seventh Fleet know his position by adding:

    "MY POSITION WITH THREE OTHER CARRIER TASK GROUPS..."

A/C The seemingly endless string of messages sent by Seventh Fleet units to Halsey was probably getting to him. Halsey's reply let VADM Kinkaid know how helpless he was by stating, "there was nothing further he could do" at his present location. Once again the miscommunication between the fleets was evident by ADM Halsey stating "...my position...". Embarked in BB NEW JERSEY, ADM Halsey would have been riding along with Task Force 34 had they been left behind to guard San Bernardino Strait. His last message told VADM Kinkaid he was indeed far to the north with the carriers, striking VADM Ozawa's decoy Northern Force.
0930 Heavy cruisers' HIJMS CHIKUMA and HIJMS CHOKAI sink.
0930 After watching heavy cruisers TONE, HAGURO, and the remaining ships of the Japanese Centre Force retreat, RADM Sprague orders the nine remaining ships of Taffy III to form "formation 5 Roger," normal cruising formation.
A/C The Battle Off Samar has now ended for the nine surviving ships of Taffy III. Of the four ships currently sunk or sinking, unexpectedly, one more escort carrier would soon join their ranks.
EVENT From the bow of the sinking ship, the last remaining men of DE ROBERTS abandon ship and jump into the water.
0935 The escort carriers of Taffy II launch eleven Avengers and eight Wildcat fighters. Only one torpedo bomber is armed with a torpedo, the remainder carry four 500-pound bombs apiece.
0940 Destroyer JOHNSTON dead in the water, becomes the focal point of Destroyer Squadron 10's gunfire. Destroyers URAKAZE, ISOKAZE, YUKIKAZE, and NOWAKI concentrate their fire on her "...like Indians circling a covered wagon...".
A/C JOHNSTON was helpless at this point.
0945 Badly battered, sinking, and unable to defend herself, DD JOHNSTON orders "abandon ship."
1000 Admiral Halsey, aboard BB NEW JERSEY, is handed a message from ADM Nimitz, Commander, U.S. Pacific Fleet, in Pearl Harbor. The message reads:

    "WHERE IS, RPT (REPEAT), WHERE IS TASK FORCE 34? RR THE WORLD WONDERS."

An irate Halsey cannot control his emotions and throws his cap to the deck.

A/C Admiral Nimitz, like Kinkaid, Sprague and most others, also believed TF 34 was guarding San Bernardino Strait.
A/C The actual message text received by BB NEW JERSEY's communications center was:

    "TURKEY TROTS TO WATER RR WHERE IS RPT WHERE IS TASK FORCE 34? RR THE WORLD WONDERS."

A/C The first and last 'sentences' were padding, separated from the "meat" of the message by double letters (RR). Padding was routinely placed on messages to confuse the enemy code breakers. When ADM Halsey was given this particular message, the words making up the end padding, "THE WORLD WONDERS," were not dropped by the communications center personnel because plausibly, they appeared to be part of the message. Admiral Halsey, knowing that the double letters "RR" indicated the words in the last sentence were padding, perceived the entire message as a calculated insult from his superior officer. An infuriated Halsey contemplated his next move...
1003 Admiral Halsey receives another message, this time from VADM Kinkaid, urgently requesting help:

    "MY SITUATION IS CRITICAL. FAST BATTLESHIPS AND SUPPORT BY AIR STRIKE MAY BE ABLE TO PREVENT ENEMY FROM DESTROYING CVE'S AND ENTERING LEYTE".

1007 Destroyer Escort USS SAMUEL B. ROBERTS (DE 413), reduced to a twisted wreck, rolls over and sinks, the third American ship of Taffy III to succumb to Centre Force.
A/C SAMUEL B. ROBERTS lost three officers and eighty-six enlisted men, many of whom died of wounds on the rafts during the next forty-eight hours.
1005 Taffy II's latest strike arrives and attacks the crippled Japanese cruisers, scoring three more hits.
1010 Destroyer USS JOHNSTON (DD 557) sinks, receiving a salute from the skipper of a Japanese destroyer as she goes down.
A/C Of JOHNSTON's 327 officers and men, only 141 survived.
1014 Heavy cruiser SUZUYA, badly damaged by previous attacks, is hit again by US carrier aircraft and is left in a sinking condition.
1030 American CV HORNET, from Vice Admiral McCain's TG 38.1, launches six fighters to search for Centre Force which is 335 miles away.

Back to Chapter 7 - Combustible, Vulnerable, & Expendable

Forward to Chapter 9 - Enter Kamikaze

Return to Book Index Page

Return to Menu Page


Honor the Missing in Action and Killed in Action of Taffy III

We do remember.  We won't forget.


Robert Jon Cox [email protected]
last revised August 29 1996
Copyright Robert Jon Cox 1996 all rights reserved
Void where prohibited.