Editorial: Why is the Revolutionary War Not Popular?

     This is something I have wondered for some time. I am fascinated by the Civil War also, but I don't completely follow why it so popular to the exclusion of other time periods, especially the Revolution. Many people become interested in the Civil War by researching their ancestors and by reading men and women's experiences in their own words.  There are many more diaries and remembrances available from the Civil War than the Revolution, and we naturally relate to people of the 1800s more easily than to the people of the 1700s. For me the 1700s are more interesting BECAUSE it was such a different world - an "Age of Reason" with a third of all birthes out of wedlock and the rich painting naked babies on the ceiling.

     Do people see the Founding Fathers as Gods who were perfect and boring?  I admit to hero worship of George Washington, and I am hardly alone.  His refusal to exploit his power for his own purposes makes him one of the great men of all time, perhaps the greatest.  But he and the others were far from perfect.  Did he try to steer his French and Indian War superiors to blaze trails in specific locations to increase the value of his land speculations?  Was he a male "gold digger" looking for a rich woman to marry to increase his wealth and influence?  What about that lengthy Revolutionary War expense account?  Did he conceive an illegitimate child with a slave?  It looks like Mr. Jefferson did.  The much beloved Benjamin Franklin split with his own son because of political differences, and Benedict Arnold was only the most infamous of a number of questionable characters.  Many Revolutionary figures were in fact self serving glory seekers or adventurers, concerned more for themselves than for any ideals.  This helps make the Revolution as interesting as any era in history, but why is there so little interest?      

     Mark Boatner wrote that a person interested in both the Revolution and the Civil War is as rare as the person who loves both London and Paris.  I am one of those rare persons, but perhaps the typical Revolution buff and the typical Civil War buff see the world differently.  Maybe it's a different political outlook, or maybe it's the absence of modern controversy concerning the Revolution.  Although arguments can be made, few people will argue that the British were in the right during the Revolution.  In contrast, the the arguments of the Civil War are frequently refought to this day.  Possibly contrary to the typical RevWar buff, I and undoubtedly others, believe that secession was legal and that the Civil War was the beginning of the destruction of the Constitution, which continues to the present, having accelerated in the 1930s and 1960s.  (See CW opinion)  Even those who disagree will probably concede that the debate over the nature of our government will never end.   The issues of the Revolutionary War are pretty well settled in people's minds, and it is all to easy to take the Revolution for granted.

     Sadly, many people today have not spent time developing an interest in politics, government, and history and are completely absorbed in their own lives and material possessions.  Today, people who still believe in the Second and Tenth Amendments are labeled kooks.  Citizens are subjected to many more taxes and oppressions than the colonists ever were, but few people seem to notice.  This is not what made America great.   Although the Revolution is full of drama and interesting characters, people will never come to appreciate the Revolution unless their interest is sparked.  Unlike Civil War battlefields, many of the battlefields and landmarks of the Revolution were lost or forgotten long ago, and we can NEVER get them back.  Sadly, there is a Civil War Preservation Trust, but not a Revolutionary War Preservation Trust.   

     Despite the fact the Revolution was a global war, I detect that it is wrongly seen as a regional, or Northern, event, and the people of the South and West just don't relate to it.  I do believe that a lot of history is North-centric and that SOME people of the North are convinced of their own cultural superiority.  This is not beneficial to the appreciation of our history.  It is a mystery to me why Ken Burns' Northern-biased Civil War program created so much interest in the war.  I have often found PBS's history programing depressing, Marxist, and inferior to cable TV, and "The Civil War" also was to some extent.  The A&E series, "The American Revolution", is a timeless classic and should have sparked as much or more interest in the Revolution, but apparently it did not.  Their recent movie, "The Crossing" also seemed to have had no great effect.  "The Patriot" with Mel Gibson may help, but it is rated R, and the numerous inaccuracies, are disappointing.  I suppose, then, that it is up to us to spread the word.  The word was spread to me in the 5th grade by a Bruce Bliven book.  If this webpage is a fraction as effective as his book, I will be happy. 


Back to Revolutionary War Virtual Battlefield Tours