If only it were that simple we would be spared the painful
task of thinking. Sadly, I believe "North Good, South Bad" is an all
too common opinion. A typical K through 12 education (for that
matter even a college education) barely touches on the war, so most people
are never exposed to a meaningful analysis of this vital time in American
history.
Below, I do not argue that the Civil War had nothing
to do with slavery or even that slavery wasn't the greatest single cause
of the war. I do argue that the war was more complex than many people
believe and that the reunification of the country and end of slavery were
probably the only good things to come from the war. Since studying
history without analysis and understanding is largely useless, I present
to you the following points and assorted opinions.
As we will see below, the causes of neither side in the Civil War were wholly
righteous.
Ante-bellum Southerners are criticized for their unwillingness to give up
slavery and for "destroying" the Union to save it. Most people from
the beginning of time have been unwilling to put the interests of the greater
good above their own; this is one of the reasons we have laws. This
was true about the North also. For some time, Northern textile workers
were hostile to abolitionists, seeing cheap Southern cotton as vital to their
own interests. Further, New England, not the South, was
the first section to propose secession - in 1815 in response the economic
hardship of the War of 1812.
Lincoln himself was a racist, having stated his belief that black people
were inferior. He opposed inter-racial marriage and supported a constitutional
amendment to ship black people to Africa, Central America, and the Caribbean.
Many Northerners were also racist. Laws were passed prohibiting
emigration of former slaves into several Northern states, and white Union
troops regularly insulted their black comrades. The 1863 draft riot
in New York City involved mobs of potential draftees murdering defenseless
black people in order to demonstrate their unwillingness to fight for
emancipation. The Emancipation Proclamation was issued well into the
war with the main purpose of preventing foreign intervention. The
Proclamation freed slaves only in certain parts of the Confederacy, where
Lincoln had no legal and little real authority. Slaves in the North,
where the federal government had legitimate authority, were freed only after
the war.
Robert E. Lee stated that a gradual emancipation was the best course. In
Lexington, Virginia Stonewall Jackson taught black people to read in violation
of state law, and Jubal Early had several mixed race children with his black
common law wife. Both Lee and Patrick Cleburne advocated giving freedom
to slaves in exchange for service in the Confederate army, and for various
reasons some Southern blacks willingly supported the Confederacy, a subject
which has been widely ignored. Union forces were known to conscript
"liberated" slaves into the army, essentially enslaving them for their own
purposes.
Lincoln's stated first goal of the war was to "save" the Union. Was
it ever lost? Clearly the federal government continued to function,
just with fewer states. Secession did not guarantee war. Many
northerners wanted the southern states to leave in peace, but Fort Sumter
changed this. Although hotheads on both sides must share
responsibility for starting the war, Lincoln's actions concerning the fort
were questionable to say the least.
The more northerly Confederate states were generally willing to stay in the
Union and seceded only after Lincoln demanded all states supply troops to
put down the "rebellion". This action and this wording clearly demonstrates
that Lincoln had no respect for the Constitution and was attempting to
fundamentally redefine the nature of the federal government. My home
state of Virginia had previously voted against secession, and many future
Confederate officers had opposed secession, but Lincoln showed them that
drastic action was required. Lee put it best when he said that a union
that had to be maintained through force of arms held no charm. Lincoln's
election, his decisions about Fort Sumter, his prosecution of an illegal
war, his meddling in military affairs, and his selection of incompetent
commanders are largely responsible for over 600,000 deaths.
Some people believe that Confederates who had sworn to protect and defend
the Constitution upon joining the US Army were traitors to their nation.
This ignores the nature of the pre-war federal government, which in
fact was forever perverted from the original intent of the founding fathers.
At the time, the American people were citizens of individual states
which were members of the United States, so when a state seceded, the
citizens of the state were no longer affiliated with the national government.
The real villains of American history are the people who have ignored
or destroyed the Constitution for their own purposes, and Abraham Lincoln
is high on my list of such
people.
Perhaps to reassure Americans of the justness of the Union cause, much has
been made of the suffering of Union prisoners at Andersonville and other
prisons. But how much do you hear about the suffering of Confederates
in Northern prisons? In many cases they were treated as badly or worse
than their Union counterparts. The people of the South were starving
by the end of the war and couldn't feed their own troops, but the Union had
no such excuse. Lincoln began the war with a policy to treat prisoners
as traitors, but backed down when he discovered that the Confederates could
and would retaliate in kind. Despite the suffering of prisoners on
both sides, Lincoln ended prisoner exchange, a Western tradition since at
least the Enlightenment. And despite the suffering of Confederate
prisoners, Union prison officials failed to use funds allocated to them and
actually returned money to the Treasury.
Draft riots, draft dodging, the Copperhead movement, and the importance
of Congressional and Presidential elections demonstrate that the war was
entirely winnable for the Confederacy. All wars are political events and
the Union was not united in its efforts. Either a serious setback or
a simple lack of progress could have turned the northern people against the
war.
The destruction of large Union forces was entirely possible. Some potentially
decisive actions were Seven Pines, the Seven Days, Shiloh, Second Manassas,
Stones River, Chancellorsville, Gettysburg, Chickamauga/Chattanooga, North
Anna, and Reams' Station. In these and other battles part or all of
a Union army was vulnerable to destruction. Although it is often implied,
the Union did not have unlimited manpower. The draft was unconstitutional
and very unpopular, and most Union troops were volunteers. Had the
supply of volunteers run out, the overwhelming Union population advantage
would have been nearly useless.
Eventually the war did become unwinnable to the Confederates. Lee made this
known to Jefferson Davis. Since military commanders must completely subordinate
themselves to civilian authorities in a representative government, if blame
exists for unnecessarily prolonging the war, it lies with Davis and the
Confederate government, not with Lee.
Bottomline: The Constitution does not prohibit secession. All
the Founding Fathers agreed on this, and it is impossible to think that the
states would have agreed to a Union if there was no way to leave it. So
the Constitution did not create an all-powerful national democracy but rather
a confederation of states in which the rights of the states and the people
were protected. The existence of the electoral college, the Bill of
Rights, and US Senate clearly shows this, and although it is frequently
ignored, the 10th Amendment specifically states that the rights not given
to the federal government are the rights of the states and of the people.
But if states do not have the right to secede, they have no rights
at all. The Civil War destroyed the government created by the founding
fathers by the might makes right method, a method the Republicans of the
time used to quash Confederates and loyal Democrats alike. Although the Civil
War freed the slaves, it ultimately enslaved us all. Continued bitterness
by many southern people and defenders of the Constitution becomes understandable
when you see the Civil War as an unjust war of conquest, or to many - the
Second War of Independence.
For an expansion on many of these arguments and on many others, please visit
the America's Caesar
website. It will no doubt provide an interesting view of Lincoln, the
Radical Republican movement, and Reconstruction. The recent book, "The
Real Lincoln: A New Look at Abraham Lincoln, His Agenda, and an Unnecessary
War" by Thomas J. Dilorenzo should help educate modern Republicans about
the radical origins of their party. Although I don't agree with the
title, see this Walter Williams
article.
Most importantly, please remember the Constitution not only when you
study history, but when you vote as well.