Editorial: North Good, South Bad?

     If only it were that simple we would be spared the painful task of thinking.  Sadly, I believe "North Good, South Bad" is an all too common opinion.  A typical K through 12 education (for that matter even a college education) barely touches on the war, so most people are never exposed to a meaningful analysis of this vital time in American history.

     Below, I do not argue that the Civil War had nothing to do with slavery or even that slavery wasn't the greatest single cause of the war.  I do argue that the war was more complex than many people believe and that the reunification of the country and end of slavery were probably the only good things to come from the war.  Since studying history without analysis and understanding is largely useless, I present to you the following points and assorted opinions.



For an expansion on many of these arguments and on many others, please visit the America's Caesar website.  It will no doubt provide an interesting view of Lincoln, the Radical Republican movement, and Reconstruction.  The recent book, "The Real Lincoln: A New Look at Abraham Lincoln, His Agenda, and an Unnecessary War" by Thomas J. Dilorenzo should help educate modern Republicans about the radical origins of their party.  Although I don't agree with the title, see this Walter Williams article.  Most importantly, please remember the Constitution not only when you study history, but when you vote as well. 


Back to Civil War Virtual Battlefield Tours