Civil War Bookstore
Strategy and Tactics
The West Point Atlas of American Wars: Volume I 1689-1900 ***** Vincent Esposito makes masterly use of maps to explain the strategy behind the Civil War and other conflicts of the era. Strategy leading up to battle and the battles themselves are well covered. In addition to the Civil War, the sections on the Mexican War and Spanish-American War are excellent. These are better maps than those on the West Point website which are simplified to fit a shorter curriculum. Readers of this book will gain an impressive understanding of the war.
|
Battle
Tactics of the Civil War **** Paddy Griffith is
the authority on military tactics. In this controversial book he argues
that instead of being the first modern war, the Civil War was the last
"Napoleonic" war. The potential of shock action was and still is ignored
in favor of firepower, and battles often degenerated into indecisive slugging
matches. Interestingly, he points out that the Union could have
equipped whole armies with repeating rifles but could not manufacture enough
ammunition to supply them. For further information on Paddy Griffith's books,
see his
website.
Attack and Die: Civil War Military Tactics and the Southern Heritage *** McWhiney and Jamieson believe that the Scotch Irish of the South were lazy and liked to drink and fight and were therefore naturally inclined to wasteful attacks in a time when the strength of defense was rising. The authors argue that the Confederacy would have been better off fighting on the defensive. I strongly disagree with these opinions and believe that the authors would be widely denounced as racists if their comments were directed toward any other ethnic group. The authors use statistics to back up their claims, but as with many things, numbers tell only part of the story. Despite a flawed argument, the book remains an influential and interesting work.
| Civil War Artillery at Gettysburg
***** By Phillip Cole. Although it was written by a
Gettysburg tour guide and it includes advice on finding specific guns at the
park, this book provides an excellent overview of artillery throughout the
war. Somewhat obscure but fascinating facts about the design of the
guns as well as the logistics and command structure behind them provide a
complete view of Civil War artillery. Although the book deals with a
very technical subject, the author does not get bogged down in jargon and
his explanations of complex topics are easy to understand.
|
General
| The
Civil War Battlefield Guide ****1/2 Hundreds of
battles are covered with topo maps used extensively. Smaller battles
are placed in relation to the larger battles and campaigns. Although
it isn't perfect, it is an indispensable touring guide.
|
The
Civil War Dictionary *** Mark M. Boatner has hundreds
of entries in this book covering every major campaign and many of the
personalities of the war. Not nearly as good as his Revolutionary War
Encyclopedia, it is still useful. Most Civil War books have this book
in their bibliographies.
Southwest Virginia
Battle of Cloyds Mountain: The Virginia and Tennessee Railroad Raid, April 29-May19, 1864 **** Howard McManus discovered and researched this forgotten Southwest Virginia battlefield. Before his research, even the location of the battlefield was unknown. This interesting battle deserves more attention than it has gotten. Not only is McManus a thorough researcher, he can write also.
Southwest Virginia in the Civil War: The Battles for Salville **** William Marvel covers all the battles for southwest Virginia, including Lewisburg, Wytheville, Droop Mountain, Cloyds Mountain, Marion, and Saltville. He also covers some of the personalities that came from, or commanded in, the area including Stuart, Floyd, Mosby, McCausland, and Jenkins. This well written book discusses the vital importance of the region and nicely ties in all the campaigns in the area.
General William Averell's Salem Raid: Breaking the Knoxville Supply Line ****1/2 This is another forgotten raid into Southwest Virginia, and I'm pleasantly surprised to see this book. After an attempt to cut the Virginia & Tennessee Railroad failed in the Droop Mountain campaign, Averell tried again, reaching Salem, Va. Despite doing some damage, Averell was very lucky to make it back to West Virginia. This well written book makes good use of maps, a necessity in dealing with the rugged terrain.
Battles and Campaigns
1861-2
Battle at Bull Run: A History of the First Major Campaign of the Civil War **** Authored by William C. Davis, this book is probably the best yet written on the battle.
To the Gates of Richmond: The Peninsula Campaign ***** Stephen Sears is an excellent writer and is author of this book on the Peninsula Campaign, from Fort Monroe to the Seven Days.
The Seven Days: The Emergence of Lee ***** by Clifford Dowdey. A very well written account of the battles with excellent analysis.
| Stonewall
in the Valley ***** Robert Tanner expertly focuses
on the strategic and operational aspects of Jackson's Valley Campaign without
ignoring the drama of the battles themselves or the personalities involved. There is never a dull
moment in this book. This newer edition reveals the influence of Lee
on the campaign. Undoubtly, this is one of the best Civil War books
ever written. It is a complete joy to read.
|
Conquering the Valley: Stonewall Jackson at Port Republic
*** 1/2 by Robert Krick. This book about Cross Keys and
Port Republic is remarkably well researched and detailed. The thorough
research is the book's strength and its weakness. It makes this book
the be all end all on the subject, but it goes into too much detail and becomes
somewhat tedious. It has excellent aerial photos and maps, which
unfortunately came as loose corrected versions in my book. Of
research interest is the author's conclusion that most soldier's accounts
are inaccurate, either inflating their part in battles or attempting to hide
the dangers and horrors they experienced from their relatives.
| Return to Bull Run: The Battle and Campaign of Second Manassas ***** John Hennessey wrote this masterpiece of campaign history. Although he covers the battle in detail, he never loses sight of the big picture. Brawner's Farm, Pope's disjointed attacks, and Longstreet's attack all make sense now. McDowell's part in the Union fiasco is also detailed. This is one of the best Civil War books ever written. |
From Cedar Mountain to Antietam ***** Edward Stackpole puts you into the heads of the commanders better than anyone else and never burdens the reader with unnecessary detail. This book covers Lee's most daring and interesting campaigns which also best show Lee's strengths and weaknesses as a commander. As with all of Stackpole's books, I give it the best compliment I can give - that children and college professors can both gain something from the book.
Landscape Turned Red: The Battle of Antietam ***** Stephen Sears does a good job explaining this complex battle, making good use of maps.
Antietam: The Photographic Legacy of America's Bloodiest Day **** Photographers brought home the horrors of war to the American people with their shocking pictures from Antietam. William Frassanito has located the exact locations these photographs were taken and shows what the places look like now.
The Fredericksburg Campaign: Drama on Rappahannock **** by Edward Stackpole. The author competently explains the battle, Union command failures, and the campaign itself, which is more interesting than you might think.
1863
Chancellorsville: Lee's Greatest Battle ***** by Edward Stackpole. The author nicely details the excellent Union plan, their advance and coordination, as well as Lee and Jackson's daring "break all the rules" victory.
They Met at Gettysburg ***** This was the first book in the wonderful series written by Edward Stackpole. Although covering the whole campaign, the book's strongest feature is its analysis of the leaders and their decisions. Stackpole points out that poor Union staff work could have cost them the battle.
The Battle of Gettysburg: A Guided Tour **** by Edward Stackpole. This is a good guide to the Gettysburg battlefield. With too many complicated War Department signs and not enough National Park Service signs, you need your own guide. This book explains the battle, the tour stops, and the important events between park service tour stops.
|
|
Gettysburg: A Battlefield Guide ***** By Mark Grimsley. This excellent battlefield guide is also an excellent short history of the battle. Written before the Pfanz trilogy was complete, I did see some differences between the two, but that detract little from the book. It provides more detail than the Stackpole tour book, and is suitable for a more advanced history buff. |
Gettysburg: The First Day **** by Harry Pfanz. This third volume of Pfanz's Gettysburg books is very good, but not quite as good as the other two. Like the other books, the author covers the fight from the top to the bottom of the chain of command. In this book, however, the decisions of the high command are not covered as well, probably because less is known. The book is somewhat oddly organized, with all the events from a particular area covered at the same time regardless of what happened elsewhere. Nevertheless, it is still probably the most comprehensive account of the action.
Gettysburg: The Second Day ***** Harry Pfanz focuses on Longstreet's attack in excellent detail without losing sight of the big picture. He eliminates the confusion of this complicated fight.
Gettysburg-Culp's Hill and Cemetery Hill ***** A companion to Gettysburg The Second Day, this book by Harry Pfanz is the definitive book on Cemetery Hill and Culp's Hill. The author was superintendent of the park for years and knows the battle better than anyone else. Pfanz gives the whole picture, top to bottom. As large as the book is, it is well worth reading.
The Gettysburg Campaign: A Study in Command **** This is a reissue of the classic book by Edward Coddington. The author describes the big and small picture of the battle and focuses on the decisions the commanders made. Coddington analyzes the leadership of the commanders and addresses the controversies of the campaign, including the failure to take Cemetery Hill the first day and the lateness of Longstreet's attack.
Pickett's Charge: A Microhistory of the Final Attack at Gettysburg ***** It says good things about George R. Stewart's classic book that it is still in print over forty years after it was first published. The author makes good use of maps, photos, and some simple math in this well written and comprehensive study of the attack.
Chickamauga: A Battlefield Guide With a Section on Chattanooga ***** By Steven Woodworth. Park service signs are often inadequately explain a battle. Your really need your own guidebook, and this is one of the best guidebooks ever written about any battlefield. Grimsley's excellent Gettysburg guide is in the same series, and I am eagerly awaiting more of the same.
1864-5
The Spotsylvania Campaign: May 7-21, 1864 **** By John Cannan. The Spotsylvania campaign was long, complicated, and indecisive. But John Cannan's concise book makes it interesting and understandable, clearing up confusing troop movements and nicely analyzing the commanders and their decisions.
|
Cold Harbor: Grant and Lee, May 26-June 3, 1864
****1/2 By Gordon Rhea. Although there are other
good books on the campaign, this is the most thoroughly researched, detailed,
and myth-busting of them all. In fact, Gordon Rhea's research puts
most other historians to shame. Important but neglected cavalry fights,
ones that many authors would footnote, are covered and their importance is
shown. Battle maps are very detailed and are more accurate than anyone
else's. Other books on the battle are confused, leading me to believe
their authors don't understand the battle they are writing about. Rhea clearly does understand,
and importantly for us, he can explain what he knows. If you want to
know everything there is to know about Cold Harbor, this is the book for
you.
|
Not
War but Murder: Cold Harbor 1864 ****
Ernest Ferguson's well written book gives a very good treatment of the whole
campaign, making good use of maps and providing excellent analysis of the
leaders and their decisions.
The Battle of Cold Harbor **** Part of the Virginia Battles and Leaders Series. The greatest strength of Louis Baltz's book is his coverage of the complicated maneuvering from the Totopotomoy to the Chickahominy. His text and maps make the campaign easy to understand, and his explanations of the battles are very good as well.
Sheridan in the Shenandoah ***** Edward Stackpole makes sense out of this complex and important campaign. Beginning with the repulse of Hunter's Raid at Lynchburg, the book follows Jubal Early through his raid to Washington and his defeats at Third Winchester, Fishers Hill, and Cedar Creek.
Petersburg Campaign: Wasted Valor June 15-18, 1864 **** By Thomas Howe. Most books concerning Petersburg gloss over the first several days when the Union had numerous opportunities to take the city and win the war. In fact, I know of no other book length treatment on these battles. Thomas J. Howe has filled the gap with his book. He covers the campaign from the top to the bottom of the chain of command, analyzing the commanders and their decisions and their effect on the rank and file. Howe's account makes Meade's generalship appear mediocre at best.
| The Last Citadel: Petersburg, Virginia, June 1864-April 1865 ***** Noah Andre Trudeau explains all the complex operations around Petersburg. Petersburg is a mystery no more. A joy to read. |
Back to Military History Bookstore
Covering Numerous Other Topics