Military History Bookstore
with Book Reviews
Most of these books I recommend, either because they present new or different ideas, cover neglected topics, or because they are masterfully written. They are rated between one and five stars, with five being excellent, four being very good, three good, and the rare book below three a waste of time and money. Below are links to specific sections.
|
Most of the reviewed books are for sale at Amazon.com. If you go to the Amazon.com website through any of the links on this website then buy a product, I earn a small commission at no extra charge to you. The Amazon.com website often has book reviews from other people, book previews, and excellent prices. Not surprisingly, I buy from them myself. I would appreciate your business |
Links to Specific Sections
General Military History and Strategy
Early Modern Warfare - Renaissance to the 19th Century The most interesting time period in history.
World War I Contrary to popular belief, WW I is not boring.
Naval See also Renaissance to the 19th Century.
History, Economic History, and Generalities The fascinating and profound. Take a look!
General Military History and Strategy
| Strategy ***** One of the great military thinkers of all time, B.H. Liddell Hart advocates "the indirect approach" instead of a bloody Clauswitzian battle. The author uses examples from ancient times to modern guerilla warfare to prove his point. Although he doesn't always understand the wars he discusses, but his concept is good.
|
Forward into Battle ***** Paddy Griffith argues that the importance of firepower has been overestimated relative to shock action. For instance, Griffith contends that Wellington's army was successful not simply because of its volley fire but more importantly from the subsequent charge. He argues that at New Orleans poor troops lacking discipline failed to take a fortified line that good troops could have taken. He details the rise of light infantry through the 1800s. Then he shows that the shock action of brief artillery bombardments and stormtrooper tactics broke through the trenches of World War I. With every technological advance and increase in firepower, people have prophesied an "empty battlefield" and neglected shock at their peril. For further information on Paddy Griffith's books, see his website.
Great Battlefields of the World **** First published in the mid 1980s and still in print, John Macdonald wrote this book that features aerial views of famous battles created with the help of computers. This shows how terrain affected the course of battle when battles have affected the course of history.
The Evolution of Weapons and Warfare **** Trevor Dupuy shows how advances in weapons technology have changed tactics from ancient to modern times.
A Genius for War: The German Army and General Staff, 1807-1945 ***** Trevor Dupuy recounts the formation of the German general staff system in the Napoleonic era and how this system created the superior German war machine of the 1800s and 1900s. The Prussian-Austrian War of 1866 and the Franco-Prussian War and well covered. The author uses statistics to show the superiority of the German army during the world wars.
The Mask of Command **** John Keegan shows how different styles of leadership were suited to their times. Keegan uses Alexander, Wellington, Grant, and Hitler as examples of hero, anti-hero, un-hero, and false hero leadership styles. We are treated to Wellington washing himself twice a day and tossing aside a chicken bone in a fit of genius. It is generally a good book, but why are the British such big fans of U.S. Grant?
War and the World: Military Power and the fate of Continents, 1450-2000 *** Like most Jeremy Black books, neglected conflicts around the world are covered, an especially refreshing change from most books. On the downside, Black jumps around a lot, often lacks coherence, is occasionally self plagarising, and makes occasional errors of fact. Warfare in Europe is neglected in favor of the rest of the world, but despite his PC smack talking about Eurocentrism, he clearly is more knowledgeable about European history.
Ancient and Medieval
|
The
Grand Strategy of the Roman Empire *****
Edward Luttwak explains how Roman grand strategy evolved as threats to the
empire changed. He shows how Augustus began a system of client states
which evolved in a fortified barrier with a reserve to react to penetrations.
Eventually, barbarian tribes formed confederacies that were able to
breach Roman defenses. In a failed response, the Romans created a defense
in depth.
|
The Reach of Rome: A History of the Roman Imperial Frontier 1st to 5th Century AD ***** Derek Williams discusses the fortifications which protected the Roman frontier and shows the ingenuity of the designers and the defenders and how the defenses were adapted to local conditions. Especially interesting are the North African defenses and the techniques to accumulate water and irrigate the desert to grow enough crops to feed the garrisons.
Art of War in the Middle Ages AD 378-1515 **** Charles Oman shows the tactical changes in medieval warfare from the rise of the armored knight to their decline due to the longbow, crude artillery, and the Swiss phalanx. The important social changes from this decline are also discussed.
Napoleonic Wars
The Art of War of Revolutionary France ***1/2 The always free thinking Paddy Griffith shows how the French Revolutionary Wars were fought, and it is not a pretty picture. He shows how radical ideology and near anarchy led to embarrassing failures. Only contrary aims among allied prevented French disaster.
|
|
The Campaigns of Napoleon ***** David G. Chandler wrote this, one of the best military history books ever written. His writing helps you visualize battles like nothing else can. In addition to the campaigns and battles, Chandler explains the Napoleonic system of war, his three strategic maneuvers, and his simple and often repeated battle method. This book is not cheap, but is worth every penny.
|
| A Military History and Atlas of the Napoleonic Wars ***** Vincent Esposito and John Elting explain and critique Napoleon's campaigns. This book and Chandler's are essential to understand the Napoleonic Wars. Complex campaigns such as Spain in 1808, Germany in 1813, and France in 1814 are much easier to understand. The concise writing provides the reader with invaluable information, insight, and opinion, including sentences like, "It was a typical heads-down go and get killed frontal attack." These maps are not the maps on the West Point website. There are one hundred more maps, all of which are more detailed than the newer website maps.
|
Blundering to Glory: Napoleons Military Campaigns **** Although Owen Connelly still believes Napoleon was a genius, he argues that much of his success was due to "scrambling."
Art of Warfare in the Age of Napoleon **** Gunther Rothenberg explains the strategy, tactics, and logistics of the Napoleonic era and the eighteenth century. Technological and tactical changes of the late 1700s are well covered along with how strategy and tactics changed through the course of the French Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars.
Eggmuhl 1809: Storm over Bavaria **** This Osprey book covers this 1809 campaign well and contains maps and photographs of the battlefield. The 3D battle maps and modern photos give an excellent sense of the fighting. The campaign itself is more difficult to follow, so keep "A Military History and Atlas of the Napoleonic Wars" handy.
Military Thought in the French Army, 1815-51 *** Always free thinking Paddy Griffith argues that the French Army of this era was progressive socially and tactically while returning to a smaller more professional force in reaction to developments late in the Napoleonic Wars. Especially interesting is the move toward light infantry and the emphasis on a "gymnastic" pace to close with the enemy. Although not as good as some Griffith books, it is an interesting look at this important transitional time.
World War I
| Real War, 1914-1918 ***** B.H. Liddell Hart knew better than anyone the "Real War"- the incompetence, lost opportunities, and eventual decisiveness of the war. Hart believes the British came very close to a breakthrough in 1915, and he downplays the importance of the tank in favor of improved infantry and artillery tactics. The first several pages include an excellent discussion of the causes of the war and the diplomacy of the pre-war period. He also discusses the argument whether the war was won in the East and Home Front or on the Western Front. |
The West Point Atlas of American Wars: Volume II 1900-1918 ****1/2 by Vincent Esposito. A smaller companion to Volume I which focused primarily on the Civil War, this book has the same concise style and the same excellent analysis. Unfortunately, the nature of the First World War makes the maps less interesting and useful than Volume I.
World War II
| Hitler's Panzers East: World War II Reinterpreted ***** In this controversial book the author argues that the decisive moment of World War II was in 1941 when, against the advice of his army commanders, Hitler diverted his armored troops to the Ukraine and away from Moscow. |
| Blood,
Tears and Folly: An Objective Look at World War II
***** Len Deighton details axis and allied accomplishments
and failures early in the war. This is a very well written book.
|
| Panzer Battles ***** F.W. von Mellinthin masterfully explains German armored warfare and tactics throughout the war. The author fought in Poland, France, Yugoslavia, North Africa, Russia, and Northwestern Europe. He analyzes the tactics of the British in North Africa, the Red Army, and the US Army in Northwest Europe. Very readable. |
Visions of Infamy: The Untold Story of How Journalist Hector C. Bywater Devised the Plans that Led to Pearl Harbor ***** William Honan discusses Hector Bywater, a British journalist and former spy, who prophesied the Pacific War and how it would be fought. Bywater died under mysterious circumstances, possibly killed under orders of Admiral Yamamoto.
Brute Force ***** by John Ellis. Sadly out of print and probably not widely read, this excellent volume shows how the Allies wasted lives and resources in the successes against the Axis starting in 1943. Mobile warfare and victory have obscured this. Ellis compares the Allied war effort to killing a bug with a sledgehammer.
Naval
Fleet Tactics and Coastal Combat ***** When Cpt. Wayne P. Hughes couldn't find a textbook on naval tactics, he wrote his own. He covers surface to surface warfare from Lissa to the present and aircraft carrier tactics from pre-World War II to the present. Especially well covered are carrier and destroyer actions of the Pacific in theory and practice. The basic idea of the book is strike effectively first.
History, Economic History, and
Generalities
| Penguin Atlas of Ancient History ***** In this series of books, Colin McEvedy concisely explains the political, diplomatic, military, and economic history of the western world. These excellent little books focus on important trends and omit unnecessary fluff. This series of books are about understanding the all-important big picture of history. | The New Penguin Atlas of Medieval History ***** by Colin McEvedy. Tribal, ethnic, and linguistic movements and migrations of the period are well covered. | Penguin Atlas of Modern History (To 1815) ***** by Colin McEvedy. This time period was full of social change and attempts to dominate Europe. | The Penguin Atlas of Recent History: Europe Since 1815 ***** by Colin McEvedy. In particular, this volume well explains the important changes in the Balkans. |
The Penguin Atlas of African History ****1/2 All of Colin McEvedy's atlases are excellent. Although I'd never had that great of interest in African history, I knew McEvedy would make it interesting. After explaining the evolution of man, the author focuses mainly on North Africa then on later European exploration and imperialism.
The Penguin Historical Atlas of the Pacific ****1/2 by Colin McEvedy. Although excellent, this is the most flawed of the series. This is due to the inadequate maps with the Burma area right at the book's crease. Especially interesting was early discussion of the races and tribes of Asia, and I would have loved to read more along these lines. I would have also have preferred the maps and discussion to extend to India or even Iran, but hopefully the author will eventually write on this too.
Wilderness at Dawn ***** This well written book by Ted Morgan follows several colonial and pioneer groups as they settle on the frontier in search of their American dream. This book of popular history is difficult to put down.
Cathedral, Forge, and Waterwheel: Technology and Invention in the Middle Ages **** The Gies show that the Middle Ages were a time full of technical innovation. They argue that the Renaissance was a natural progression from the Middle Ages.
The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers ****1/2 Paul Kennedy investigates the many attempts to gain control of Europe, the strengths and weakness of the great powers, and the reasons for the emergence of the western world. His forecast of a Japanese future, however, shows that historians should stick with the past.
War and the Rise of the State: The Military Foundations of Modern Politics ***** By Bruce Porter. I started reading this book solely to learn about the eighteenth century, but I found it to be so profound and well written that I had to read it the whole book. Everyone who cares about freedom should read this book. Among the first sentences Porter says that like many people, when he first started to study history he found wars to be an annoying interruption of progress, but that he grew to appreciate that after each war the world was somehow different. The how and why are the subject of the book. Porter shows how war and the need to pay for war has led to increasing state power and larger government. Porter shows that in most European states kings used war to quash representative government, but he also shows the exceptions - Switzerland, Sweden, the Netherlands, Britain, and America. Porter shows how different circumstances in these countries helped lead to representative government of some kind. The 20th century tyrannies of fascism and communism and the rise of the welfare state are also convincing explained.
The Wealth and Poverty of Nations ***** By David Landes. This is one of the best economic history books I have ever read. His arguments may not explain everything, but he shows how cultural differences help explain economic success and failure. These cultural differences are typically ignored by economists who assume a perfect "Newtonian" world or who refuse to question the dogma of political correctness. It's time to question the assumptions. This book was a bestseller for good reason.
| The Origins of the Modern World: A Global and Ecological Narrative ***** Or "Every anti-Eurocentric Argument Ever Made by Respected Historians," by Robert B. Marks. Not being a leftist myself, the term Eurocentric conjures up thoughts of tie dye wearing, pot smoking hippies who hate America, western civilization, and the Industrial Revolution. This book shows that the anti-Eurocentric crowd have some interesting thoughts on how the world has developed. They argue that due to greater agricultural productivity in the East, presumably meaning rice, individual Asians were richer than Europeans until the Industrial Revolution. As a result, Europeans had to use force to engage in Eastern trade. Also argued is that coal was the vital force of the Industrial Revolution. Before coal, people's energy expenditure was limited to the sun's annual output. I don't know how valid these arguments are, but they are refreshing and different and an elegant explanation of the otherwise unexplainable. |
| Guns, Germs, and Steel ***** Because a book named "Geography, Germs, and Agriculture" wouldn't sell as well. Jared Diamond argues that geography is the reason why civilization developed in Eurasia and not the Western Hemisphere, Africa, or the Pacific. With a large number of plants and animals that could be domesticated in Eurasia, people were able to create an agricultural surplus and engage in activities other than agriculture. The emergence of agriculture is among the most interesting sections of the book, but sadly he says little about the history which follows. This is a very well written book, but the author has a clear liberal bias, even questioning the superiority of our modern way of life. He feels the need to repeatedly declare that he is not a racist, an obvious waste of his and our time, probably for lazy leftist book reviewers who will read a page or two and declare him a racist. I still highly recommend it. |
| Catastrophe: An Investigation into the Origins of the Modern World ***** The author convincingly argues that a massive volcanic explosion in the early 500s changed history with famine, plague, and migrations, affecting the whole world from China to Europe to the Western Hemisphere. Impressive flowcharts show the many feedback loops which make history so interesting. Among the many effects are the rise of Islam and the beginning of Judaism in Eastern Europe. |
The Little Ice Age: How Climate Made History, 1300-1850 ***** Brian Fagan shows how a global warm-spell in the late medieval period led to the Viking discovery of American and how the later cooling affected European development. Famine, flood, and plague were caused by the little Ice Age and had profound affects on agriculture. With less rigid social structures, the Netherlands and Britain adapted, creating a capitalist agriculture which created an ample surplus of food, allowing farm workers to move to industrial jobs. The resulting pollution now threatens our own environmental crisis. Ancient feudal law and stiff social hierarchy in France prevented agricultural progress and helped spark revolution. Heavy rains in Ireland led to the introduction and heavy reliance on the potato, turning the potato blight of the 1840s into a severe famine and leading to the massive migration to America.
Floods, Famines, and Emperors : El Nino and the Fate of Civilizations **** Brian Fagan shows the effects of El Nino on South America and Central America. This is a very good book, but not as good as "The Little Ice Age."
Bionomics: Economy As Ecosystem ***** Michael Rothschild shows how the economy is similar to nature and the process of evolution. He argues that capitalism naturally occurs when man is free. He compares DNA with the printing press and modern methods of information transfer. Rothschild takes pains to say he is not a social Darwinist, as if it is a terrible shameful disease.
The Moral Animal: Evolutionary Psychology and Everyday Life ***** Robert Wright shows that the human mind has evolved over time along with the body. He shows that morals are genetically encoded but are not entirely concrete since different life and reproductive strategies can be successful. This book along with the one above will help you see the world very differently. Unlike the previous author, Wright to does not see social Darwinism as a disease.
| Nonzero: The Logic of Human Destiny ***** Although endorsed by Bill Clinton and somewhat leftist, this Robert Wright sequel to "The Moral Animal" is a profound discussion of human history and evolution. Wright argues that human history shows clear signs of society gaining complexity to the benefit of almost everyone. This is achieved by nonzero sum games in which typically each side benefits to some degree. He shows how "nonzero sumness" has affected evolution, making probable the emergence of intelligent life from lesser forms. The most interesting historical discussion is the emergence of agriculture. He shows that hunter-gatherers practice a crude proto-agriculture and argues that the emergence of agriculture was a predictable, natural event. |
Back to John's Military History Page
Back to Revolutionary War Virtual Battlefield Tours
Back to Civil War Virtual Battlefield Tours
Back to Armored Fighting Vehicles Page