Comments on Col. William Hill's memoirs of the revolution
HOME       BIBLIO      

Comments on Col. William Hill's memoirs of the revolution

NOTE: These comments are discussion of this source by individual members of the history committee and do not represent consensus of the committee, nor necessarily the final conclusions of the member making the comments.

John Robertson:

This book is useful as a first-person account of the Battle at Rocky Mount, and for other details of the time/place. It is extremely biased, negatively, in anything related to Col. James Williams. In considering the Sumter-Williams enmity, it should not be taken seriously until one has read James Williams, An American Patriot in the Carolina Backcountry by William T. Graves, Writers Club Press, 2002. Regrettably, since Williams died at Kings Mountain, he never had the chance to tell his side of the story, and Hill's twisted account of Williams has been picked up by writers from Draper to Buchanon.

TOP    HOME