| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
Answer to 1:
Absolutley. Hitler would have certainly got into it a short time later anyway. Quite probably with a much more fearsome and better prepared and equipped military than that which he literally 'possessed' in 1939, especially at sea and in the air. Given the purile complacency of the British and French Governments of the later 30's, with the Western economies decimated and bankrupt as they were, Chamberlin may still well have been in office. If that was the case, by 1943 the British military would have been wrecked from the inside, more so than it already was. The French may well have actually triggered the entire thing anyway, they were still spewing about 1870 - even after WWI. Weak governments could not stand up to Hitler - historical fact - and that was what enabled Hitler to get as far as he did in the first place, got him further and sooner!
The War when it came, in fact provided the release that brought the west out of the economic depression. That really started as a result of the blind excess from the 1920's, brought in turn out of the horror of WWI !!!
Answer 2:
a. If Stalin had joined the Axis, then the world must have been divided between the Nazi's and Soviets (on paper at least). America may have come out of isolation a little too late. Russia possibly obtained a (temporary) safe European rear and proceed to revamp the 1904-05 debacle, but to a better conclusion. (Could you imagine a 1941 Russo-Japanese conflict for real?).
b. I guess Stalin wasn't happy with his proposed share from the start. Stalin and 'share' shouldn't really be used in the same sentence, he doesn't appear to be the sharing and caring type. No way, not after almost an entire adulthood on the edge of potential oblivion.
Ultimatley such a proposal may have sent a sixth sense tingling down Stalin's spine - he may well have reasoned that the Soviet Union could be next.
Naturally that's all my own opinion. As Churchill said: "...opinionated convicts all.." yep that's me mate and the feelings mutual !
21 October 2000, 14:21:38
97.
military
Molotov - Ribbentrop Pact Oct 20, 22:13
Threads navigation: 97 >>> 96
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 79, visitors today 13, now 6 |