Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Oleg: re: Is Antony Beevor�s Stalingrad book good?

The main problem I have with this book is that it's mostly written from the German point of view. I'm not saying it's biased, the author does attempt to be fairly objective, but the book constantly slips into the German POV, as if the Germans are the main character. The biggest problem, however, is scarcity of Soviet sources on the battle, especially secondary sources. This disregard for Soviet historiography makes the story rather dry and schematic on the Soviet side. On the German side, there is nothing new. Also, if you're interested in the military planning and operational details, this is NOT the book.

19 October 2000, 22:04:19

92. Jukka Juutinen Is Antony Beevor�s Stalingrad book good? Oct 19, 15:39

Juhis re: Is Antony Beevor�s Stalingrad book good? Oct 19, 16:30
Jukka Juutinen re: Is Antony Beevor�s Stalingrad book good? Oct 19, 17:55
  • Oleg re: Is Antony Beevor�s Stalingrad book good? Oct 19, 22:04
     Valera Potapov Very good!! (-) Oct 19, 23:41
    gennady re: I like it Oct 20, 13:41
     Nick re: The best I have read!(On the subject) (-) Oct 20, 14:13
  • Threads navigation:  93 <<<  92  >>> 91

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 117, visitors today 51, now 44