Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Mark Conrad: re: Did Kommisars have any training?

It seems to me that a good number of postwar memoirs from combat units were written by commissars. Fromt the ones I've looked at, a typical commissar was an enlisted man with a better than average ability to read and write. He sometimes had been promoted to junior NCO rank when he opted for training as a sub-unit political officer. After a short training course, he would go back to his old unit with his new job. So the commissar was expected to be quite familiar with his men. The memoirs, naturally, don't mention executing people. Rather, the commissars help out in morale, information, arranging field entertainment, and the like. While they might have an eye out for spies and such, much of the commissar's duties were what in other armies would be done by the chaplain, morale officer, or recreation officer. In the memoirs I've seen, the commissar had no illusion about who ran the unit: the military commander. He had great respect for the combat commander, and could be directed by him as to where to aim his morale-boosting efforts.
I think a Soviet soldier would be more nervous about running into men from a pure NKVD unit roving the battlefield rather than fear his own unit's commissar. I THINK, but have no proof, that a sub-unit commissar would turn over any bad boys to an NKVD unit for serious treatment.

Mark Conrad

19 October 2000, 16:01:54

90.  Brent Role of Penal Battalions Oct 18, 22:10

 Brent Whoops! Supposed to be Shock Troops Thread (-) Oct 18, 22:11
Men re: Whoops! Supposed to be Shock Troops Thread Oct 19, 00:08
Craig Burnett re: Role of Penal Battalions Oct 19, 00:21
Oleg re: Role of Penal Battalions Oct 19, 00:36
 Arashekino re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 19, 04:16
Craig Burnett re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 19, 09:10
  • Mark Conrad re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 19, 16:01
  • Whitey Bulger re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 20, 05:45
     Sergei K. Some commissars went to different extreme Oct 19, 16:49
    Craig Burnett re: Some commissars went to different extreme Oct 20, 06:34

    Threads navigation:  91 <<<  90  >>> 89

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 133, visitors today 67, now 60