| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
Hope I didn't start anything with the penal/shock battalion enquiry, but, grunts being grunts and propaganda being what it is, I imagine that quite a few commisars may have earned themselves posthumous awards...courtesy of their own side - but never would it ever be reported, let alone known in the West at the time. Even now, with the latest information available on this site, I have never (for example), seen a colour picture of a WWII Soviet Tank in a tri-camouflage scheme - and I'm not an ignorant person. Additionally, the sheer Titanic nature of the conflict in Western Russia would dwarf any small details such as a low ranking commissar getting one in the back of the head. Vietnam is not the only area of ops where discontent soldiers finalized an officers account - but due to the 'freedom-of-the-press' ethic and hysteria surrounding that particular adventure, the extremley few cases of such happening have become a legend that EVERYONE was doing it - which is not the case.
Kruschev was a commissar during WWII, as was Brezhnev. Both went onto the ultimate leadership position within their nation and both had outstanding front-line service records.
Most of the early years commissars did not have formalized military training, but quite a few did and many also learned on the job during the war against the White Russians - they earned their hooks the hard way: doing a very dirty job, with very hard men in a very bad situation.
On the other hand, I reckon the pure idiot bully types would not have lasted very long at the front, either with their own men or with the Germans, or most especially with Joe Stalin himself. As a final note, the Germans also had Penal units. The soldiers did often mutiny on both sides - but mostly when they were LOSING.
I have to agree with you though, where did they get those guys?!! (I think not many would have survived in any unit I or some of my mates might have been in!).
19 October 2000, 09:10:52
90.
Brent
Role of Penal Battalions Oct 18, 22:10
Threads navigation: 91 <<< 90 >>> 89
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 131, visitors today 65, now 58 |