Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Oleg: re: Role of Penal Battalions

Depending on the period, it could be very easy to get into a penal detachment. Anthony Beevor in "Stalingrad" describes several cases which show that in the summer of '42 Soviet military justice was a little too harsh. From memory, there was a case where a crew of tank conspired to desert to the Germans, but one of them refused, so they pulled a gun, forced him out, and drove off. The guy was court martialed and received a death sentence for failure to stop the deserters. Judging by this, you can imagine how many people were sentenced to penal detachments. I think this is due to the fact that the commissars were panicing because of low morale and went to extremes to fix the situation.

19 October 2000, 00:36:27

90.  Brent Role of Penal Battalions Oct 18, 22:10

 Brent Whoops! Supposed to be Shock Troops Thread (-) Oct 18, 22:11
Men re: Whoops! Supposed to be Shock Troops Thread Oct 19, 00:08
Craig Burnett re: Role of Penal Battalions Oct 19, 00:21
  • Oleg re: Role of Penal Battalions Oct 19, 00:36
     Arashekino re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 19, 04:16
    Craig Burnett re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 19, 09:10
    Mark Conrad re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 19, 16:01
    Whitey Bulger re: Did Kommisars have any training? Oct 20, 05:45
     Sergei K. Some commissars went to different extreme Oct 19, 16:49
    Craig Burnett re: Some commissars went to different extreme Oct 20, 06:34
  • Threads navigation:  91 <<<  90  >>> 89

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 130, visitors today 64, now 57