Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Sergei K.: Three sources of dislike for Suvorov

Dear Reigo, without repeating what is said in Oleg's message "Suvorov convincing?" (And I agree 100% with him), here is my reasons to be so harsh in condemning Suvorov:

A) He is very biased with facts representation and interpretations. He handle the facts in the same fashion as communist journalists did in the past, so his training is showing.
B) He lies very often. The list is so long it's much easier to tell where he wasn't lying. If wish you may bring in some "facts" from any of his books we can discuss it in a separate thread. But the full analysis of his opuses would probably take up few large volumes.
C) And last, but not least, one of the major point that Suvorov bring into discussion is that he alleges that it was actually Stalin who wanted to conduct war of aggression on poor but nice guy Hitler and he really gets very excited in condemning that crime against humanity. Well, let suppose that he is right, that every word in his books is golden truth. Then what? I say, if Stalin would start a war with Nazi Germany in 1941 he would deserve every Nobel Peace Prize from 1917 to 1991. This would be a most noble feat of communist system and probably the only justification for its existence. Reasons? Let suppose first, that Stalin would won that war (reasonable, since USSR won the war from much worst beginning). Then in 1945 Eastern Europe would be controlled by Soviet troops and we know the rest..... BUT, most of the civilian casualties of USSR would be avoided. That give us 15-20 million of lives. Then we have 6 million of Jews not being gassed, Gypsies, people of Eastern Europe and probably many of German lives being be spared of years of carpet bombing by Allies. Something like plus 30 millions of living souls saved of untimely and horrible death by that creep Stalin. Now, what is wrong with this picture? Why any sane person would be so up against such a scenario so he would write not one but two (or three?) books condemning that?

18 October 2000, 20:32:40

72. Whitey Bulger How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 05:42

 Arashekino re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 09:32
 Valera Potapov re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 10:38
Mike Johnson Good response, Valera Oct 13, 14:54
military re: Good response, Valera Oct 13, 18:56
Scott Schaffer His intelligence certainly didn't miss it. Oct 13, 19:26
 Oleg Suvorov strikes again? Oct 13, 21:42
Oleg re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 21:47
 military re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 22:52
Mike Johnson re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 03:46
 Men re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 13, 23:58
 military re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 09:00
David Woolbright re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 21:58
 Henry Oster re: Ideological war Oct 14, 09:29
 military buffer zone?! Oct 14, 23:33
Oleg Common misconception Oct 15, 22:07
 Amedeo Matteucci re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 14, 12:34
 Arashekino re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 14, 18:38
Oleg re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 20:47
David Woolbright re: How did Stalin miss this? Oct 14, 22:04
 military re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 14, 22:08
 Lev re: Thunder on the Dnepr/Industrial relocation Oct 15, 00:43
Henry Oster re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 16, 08:04
 military to Henry Oster Oct 18, 21:44
Mike Johnson re: to Henry Oster Oct 20, 00:01
military to Mike Johnson Oct 20, 23:31
 Henry re: Pavlov Oct 22, 00:04
Oleg re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 15, 22:17
Sergei K. re: Suvorov strikes again? Oct 16, 04:20
Oleg re: Thunder on the Dnepr Oct 16, 20:49
 military once again Oct 17, 15:41
Oleg military, you're jumping to conclusions Oct 17, 19:42
 Lev re: once again Oct 18, 00:52
Brad Sallows Airfield locations Oct 18, 04:03
Sergei K. Sure, lets do it again Oct 18, 06:13
Reigo re: Sure, lets do it again Oct 18, 14:13
Oleg Suvorov convincing? Oct 18, 18:11
 military Oleg it's you who's jumping to conclusions Oct 18, 20:07
  • Sergei K. Three sources of dislike for Suvorov Oct 18, 20:32
     military re: Three sources of dislike for Suvorov Oct 18, 22:31
     Oleg military, you haven't read Suvorov! Oct 18, 23:54
    Sergei K. Suvorov-book #12 Oct 19, 06:10
    Oleg re: Suvorov-book #12 Oct 19, 22:20
    �3, re: military, you haven't read Suvorov! (-) Oct 19, 15:53
     military re: military, you haven't read Suvorov! Oct 19, 19:11
    Sergei K. Exellent collection of webpages! Oct 19, 22:40
    military Sergey, I'll tell you the whole story Oct 20, 00:05
    Sergei K. Military: Am I too fast? Oct 20, 00:39
    military re: Military: Am I too fast? Oct 20, 21:41
     Oleg re: Exellent collection of webpages! Oct 20, 00:17
    Sergei K. Sovorov's book count -11, anybody else? Oct 19, 05:53
    (---) Sergey nothing's wrong Oct 19, 22:22
    Sergei K. re: Sergey nothing's wrong Oct 20, 00:05
     military re: Sergey nothing's wrong Oct 20, 21:44
     Arashekino re: I must agree with Sergei Oct 20, 22:46
     military That's it! (+) Oct 18, 19:32
     Arashekino re: So what's wrong with Stalin as aggressor? Oct 19, 04:08
    Mike Johnson Appreciation for info on Suvorov Oct 19, 16:58
  • Threads navigation:  73 <<<  72  >>> 71

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 280, visitors today 214, now 206