Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Jari Lievonen: Clarification to the question

Hi,

Perhaps I fraised the question wrong because it has been misunderstood. I was refering to the number of culprints. Brianb claimed that more Germans than Russians were quilty of these deeds. I just wanted to hear how he deducted this (see below). My first comment on "two brutal" regimes was more inclined to point out that both regimes were ready to kill for political, racial, national etc reasons without hesitation.

German terror was usually well organized but relatively few soldiers were needed to carry it out. In addition many deaths occured when people were transported, used as slave labour etc. How much and what kind of war crimes Wehrmacht soldiers did is a grey area in history. At least rape and looting were likely to happen en masse as German soldiers were told that they will not be punished.

Russians on the other hand acted in vengeance as has been pointed out and in Germany proper they were encouraged to do so. Ofcourse NKVD and other security organizations were capable of organized terror as well and it certainly was used. Anyway, the above makes it very hard to say on which side there were more people involved in war crimes.

Regards,

Jari

Regards,

Jari

18 October 2000, 09:24:23

71. Whitey Bulger War Crimes Oct 13, 05:38

 Arashekino re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 13, 09:13
Alex Hellmund re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 13, 22:34
 Arashekino re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 14, 18:32
Wen Jin It should be pointed out that Oct 14, 04:45
JWB re: War Crimes Oct 13, 09:32
Mathias Forsberg re: Sow the wind, reap a storm Oct 14, 04:22
 Oleg re: War Crimes Oct 13, 21:37
 Amedeo Matteucci re: War Crimes Oct 13, 17:38
brianb I'm with Oleg Oct 13, 23:59
 D�nes Bernad Excerpt from Ilya Ehrenburg's book 'Vojna' (no comment) Oct 14, 06:45
Paul Spitzer re: Excerpt from Ilya Ehrenburg's book 'Vojna' (no comment) Oct 17, 01:23
JWB re: War Crimes Oct 14, 08:23
brianb re: War Crimes Oct 13, 21:08
Jari Lievonen How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 10:11
 Arashekino re: How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 18:17
Lee Dowd re: How can you tell?????? Oct 17, 18:54
Oleg That's easy Oct 17, 19:10
Lee Dowd re: That's easy Oct 17, 21:33
  • Jari Lievonen Clarification to the question Oct 18, 09:24
    Oleg re: Clarification to the question Oct 18, 18:16
     Paul Spitzer re: Clarification to the question Oct 19, 00:50
    Peter re: Clarification to the question Oct 20, 14:52
    Oleg re: Clarification to the question Oct 20, 19:18
    Peter re: Clarification to the question Oct 21, 10:36
    Sergei K. Yeah, this really clarifies the question Oct 23, 15:48
    Jari Lievonen To Paul and Oleg Oct 19, 17:02
    Sergei K. re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 19, 18:53
    Peter re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 14:58
    Sergei K. re: To Paul and Oleg II Oct 20, 17:25
    Peter re: To Paul and Oleg II Oct 21, 10:48
    Sergei K. re: To Peter (+) Oct 23, 06:05
    Oleg re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 17:27
    Max re: To Paul and Oleg Oct 20, 20:13
    Sergei K. re: To Max Oct 23, 07:21
  • Threads navigation:  72 <<<  71  >>> 70

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 320, visitors today 254, now 29