Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Jux: re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist

Doug: partially you�re right, it is of course, dangerous to any civilized society to crucify people how they view a part of recent history. However, as a historical issue the Holocaust is unusually sensitive. It would be much more safer to write a book claiming anything else from the subject sphere of WW2. The famous philosopher, Theodor Adorno once said, "Auschwitz begins wherever someone looks at a slaughterhouse and thinks: they're only animals." And any attempts to "slightly" distort the historical facts about this thoroughly planned industrial massacre of millions of innocent people must be corrected immediately. Otherwise we only pave way to new tragedies. History is an interesting thing to research, but during the twenty-five years I�ve been reading about the Holocaust, I have grown to understand the final irony: history usually teaches us nothing. Think about the conflicts in the former Yugoslavian area, for example. Concentration camps and massacres. Would the murder organizations there only been more effective, we would have been witnessing new Auschwitzes, sadly indeed we almost did. This is the point I want to emphasize. We must not give an inch of foot-hold to any revisionist thinking in this matter. Moreover I agree with both Lev and also Mr. McDonald, he gives a good conclusion to this debate saying many different (and more reliable) historians doubt the accuracy of Mr. Irving�s writings. From this we must make our conclusions. I am not in any way trying to say anyone reading Irving is stupid, but reading other reliable and well-known books parallel with Mr. Irving�s books should help to understand his continual efforts to obscure the facts.

16 October 2000, 11:09:24

70. Whitey Bulger Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 05:33

 Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 15:02
Alex Hellmund Irving/Hilfiger Oct 13, 22:27
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 00:58
 Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 11:10
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 16:33
 Lev re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 23:38
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:02
Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:38
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 04:18
Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 01:00
  • Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 11:09
  •  Mark Conrad re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 04:02
    Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 09:11

    Threads navigation:  71 <<<  70  >>> 69

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 345, visitors today 279, now 34