Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Whitey Bulger: Soviet Union vs Japan, 1945 (Speculative History)

Hello all,

Assume for the sake of this post that the Manhattan Project of the United States failed to produce a nuclear weapon by the summer of 1945.

Assume that the Soviet Union still made the promise to FDR & Churchill at Yalta to attack Japan 90 days after Germany capitulated, and the Red Army moved against Japan's Kwantung Army in Manchuria and Northern China in August of '45.

As the war would not have ended a week after the Soviet intervention, as really occured when Hirohito made the surrender announcement on August 15, would the Russians have swept across China that autumn?

Would Chaing Kai-Shek's government have been replaced by that of Mao, whom the Soviets may have been under the false assumption that he could be "Moscow's man" in Peking?

How would the US/UK have responded to this (Cold War starting early, before the Japanese laid down their arms)?

Maybe the Russians would have stayed with Chaing, whom they had supported openly with arms and aid in the late 1930s.

Furthermore (sorry, this post is getting a bit long), would Soviets have contributed troops to the land invasion of the Japanese home islands? Did the Soviets have a sufficient naval prescense in the region to support such an operation? It took the world's largest two navies (US & UK) an incredible amount of resources just to deliver and support the cross-Channel invasion in June of '44. And Soviet land logistics in the assault on Germany were never the best, leaving the Red Army to often live on forage.

For those of you who have stuck with this lengthy discussion-starter I offer my thanks.

Whitey Bulger

15 October 2000, 04:34:22

  • 79. Whitey Bulger Soviet Union vs Japan, 1945 (Speculative History) Oct 15, 04:34

    Oleg re: Soviet Union vs Japan, 1945 (Speculative History) Oct 15, 22:23
     Lee Dowd re: Soviet Union vs Japan, 1945 (Speculative History) Oct 16, 15:49
     Arashekino re: Soviet Union vs Japan, 1945 (Speculative History) Oct 16, 04:50
  • Threads navigation:  80 <<<  79  >>> 78

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 199, visitors today 133, now 126