Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Doug: re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist

I don't think I need to read the transcripts (though maybe you should read more of his books before passing judgement on him).

My problem is not with the court case, but rather with those who dismiss ALL his historical work due to the fact that he has controversial opinions. Its a silly idea to label historians as this or that. If someone has a problem with something he has done historically, then deal with that issue. And yet all his detractors, here included, don't do that. They prefer to generalize. I guess its easier than making a true historical argument, to go after the historian rather than the history.

15 October 2000, 04:18:13

70. Whitey Bulger Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 05:33

 Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 15:02
Alex Hellmund Irving/Hilfiger Oct 13, 22:27
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 00:58
 Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 11:10
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 16:33
 Lev re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 23:38
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:02
Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:38
  • Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 04:18
    Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 01:00
    Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 11:09
  •  Mark Conrad re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 04:02
    Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 09:11

    Threads navigation:  71 <<<  70  >>> 69

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 343, visitors today 277, now 32