Military Forum Archive #5

Military ForumOther Forum Archives
Code of Conduct


Alexei McDonald: re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist

Well, if you read the court reports as the case went along, you will have noted that many of the lies and distortions that Irving peddled are indeed recorded and dissected. If you didn't, then perhaps you should go back and do so rather than ask us about them at second or third-hand!

I will say that the only book of Irving's I have read is "Trail of the Fox" which was a very enlightening read. It appears to be the source of a great deal of misinformation about Rommel's life and career. For example, the myth that "Infanterie greift an" was a bestseller and that it first brought Rommel to Hitler's attention is promulgated by Irving, for what reason I can't say.

15 October 2000, 00:38:31

70. Whitey Bulger Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 05:33

 Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 15:02
Alex Hellmund Irving/Hilfiger Oct 13, 22:27
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 00:58
 Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 11:10
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 16:33
 Lev re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 14, 23:38
Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:02
  • Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 00:38
    Doug re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 15, 04:18
    Alexei McDonald re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 01:00
    Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 16, 11:09
  •  Mark Conrad re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 04:02
    Jux re: Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 17, 09:11

    Threads navigation:  71 <<<  70  >>> 69

    Statistics:  threads 97, records 1045
    hits today 342, visitors today 276, now 31