| Military Forum | Other Forum Archives |
| Code of Conduct |
And yet no one has posted any historical items he has gotten incorrect in his books...
As for his quotes, assuming they are his...
In the first one he admits that Auschwitz was a brutal camp ( true) , that large numbers of people died there (true), and that large numbers of innocent people died all over Europe (Malmedy, Kiev, Warsaw, etc.) What is inccorrect about this? Ok, maybe he does disagree on some of the conventional issues regarding the holocaust, but lets remember this is the only historical event where no dissent is allowed. Its the only event where you can be thrown in jail in some enlightened western countries ( thank god for the first amendment) for any disagreeal. Even if he is dead wrong on this issue does that mean he is, as a historian, to be totally dismissed?
As for the second quote, it has real validity. it would be tough to debate here the merits of 1900 England, but he is entitled to his opinion that aristocratic England was not worth the deaths of these working class boys.
Its silly to dismiss a historian outright because yo disagree with some of his positions. It is downright dangerous to crucify people for how they view a part of recent history; any part.
15 October 2000, 00:02:55
70. Whitey Bulger Neo Nazi or Honest Journalist Oct 13, 05:33
Threads navigation: 71 <<< 70 >>> 69
|
Statistics: threads 97, records 1045 hits today 341, visitors today 275, now 30 |